News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sgt. Pepper’s to get new Atmos mix: current version ‘does... by shoo on Friday July 30, 2021 @08:07PM (#28013944)
> the sound that was recorded and post processed at the time and released is the correct one

that's a fun angle - what is the "correct" sound?

a different way to define the "correct" sound could be to claim that experience of listening to the band playing live is the one true correct "sound". In principle you could try to approximately recreate that live sound using a live beatles cover band or some kind of computer simulated beatles [+].

but that perspective of "correct" being a live listening experience ignores the contribution of production to the end product that was shipped & listened to, as you're advocating for.

[+] e.g. try to simulate the sound of all the instruments and the vocals from first principles or something, perhaps fitting them to the actual recordings using some belief about the observation model & error model of how the true sounds would have gotten recorded/distorted/mangled/mixed into the recorded sounds, using the standard equipment and techniques of the day. now we've turned the problem into an arbitrarily hard ill-defined inverse problem, so we can probably make it sound like however we want depending on what assumptions we make, so arguably this is a weird and overly complex way of producing one of many possible remixes or reinterpretations.

Re:Sgt. Pepper’s to get new Atmos mix: current version ‘does... by gerdesj on Friday July 30, 2021 @08:24PM (#28014025)
"that's a fun angle - what is the "correct" sound?"

I think you are absolutely correct here and I crapped out! - there is no correct.

There is no correct sound but there might be "authentic" sound or perhaps the original sound. The thing is I don't think you can go back on the past when several people who were there are now dead and the rest of them and my tiny recollection are well over 50 odd years old.

Basically, what I'm asking for is: go easy on history.

Re:Sgt. Pepper’s to get new Atmos mix: current version ‘does... by onionisafruit on Friday July 30, 2021 @08:13PM (#28013976)
Did The Beatles ever play Sgt Pepper's live? I'm too young to remember, but I think that was from after they stopped playing live.
Re:Sgt. Pepper’s to get new Atmos mix: current version ‘does... by BurningFrog on Friday July 30, 2021 @08:42PM (#28014123)
Yes, they stopped touring the year before.

These songs were only ever fully performed in the studio.

Re:Sgt. Pepper’s to get new Atmos mix: current version ‘does... by shoo on Friday July 30, 2021 @08:14PM (#28013983)
i am not a beatles fan, i have no idea. presumably they played it live (or the component parts of it) during recording.

if they never played it live, it makes the idea of regarding the live sound as the "true" sound even more absurd.

Re:Sgt. Pepper’s to get new Atmos mix: current version ‘does... by onionisafruit on Friday July 30, 2021 @08:18PM (#28014001)
That's what I was getting at. There's no live baseline to compare it to in this case.