(I want an article about what the Prophet Mohammed said about autism, and how we can make a better, more Islamic social movement. ... Actually we can probably find a Catholic analogue of that, if we look.)
They make this clear in the following disingenuous paragraph:
> Historically, both ‘psy’ and neurosciences have been mobilised to justify large-scale social injustices in democratic countries, from confinement to forced sterilisation and hormone treatments to ‘cure’ aberrant sexualities. We must be under no illusions here. However, it doesn’t make sense to denigrate one and eulogise the other. Indeed, often it’s psychologists taking a ‘softer’ approach to human motivation that’s served to ward off more draconian approaches to brain-based difference. For example, when eugenicists such as Carlos Blacker in the UK equated ‘mental deficiency’ with social and economic redundancy after the Second World War in order to advocate for sterilisation, it was psychologists such as Neil O’Connor and Beate Hermelin who argued that psychological and social intervention was always preferable.
It's disingenuous because it says
> it doesn’t make sense to denigrate one and eulogise the other.
but then it immediately goes about setting up associations of badness with the "hard", sciency, "brain" approach (which, y'know, led to eugenics), and of better-ness with the "soft" "psy" approach, which is more "embedded in a historical context".
Let's be clear what this is: It's a power-grab by a humanities person who wants to colonize this new identity-group on behalf of his field.
It's the highbrow left-version of the thing Trump does when he tries to convince "ordinary (white) Americans" that they should go with him, and his ideology. It's a grifter showing up in the hopes of riding you to a career.
The whole article reads like pointless nitpicking to me; there's plenty to criticize about the neurodiversity movement but it's very implausible that most of its advocates wouldn't be very clearly aware of the points OP is trying to make. The overall approach OP is trying to push here seems rather disingenuous, tbh.
The idea of the immutable self is definitely fiction, but it is a useful fiction which we use to prevent people trying to "cure" autism so we can instead be accepting and humane. It shifts the onus of change onto society instead of the individual, and ties in neatly with the social model of disability by doing so.
By tacitly attacking the idea of the immutable self, the author opens the door to "cures" for autism, homosexuality, and a variety of other things which we're currently forced to accept.
It may be the case that all that is solid melts into air but academics like this one accelerate that process instead of slowing it.