News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Opinion on “5” == 5 by int_19h on Thursday July 29, 2021 @11:40PM (#28004194)
> That wouldn't be an improvement, tho.

That would be an improvement, surely? Just not one that is good enough...

But at that point we're discussing a much broader problem (or feature, depending on who you ask) with dynamic typing in general, which is different and orthogonal to the problem with implicit conversions that "5"==5 is all about: whether it's an error in the first place or not.

> This is a solved problem in statically typed languages.

It's only a solved problem if you follow the patterns consistently, which many modern languages do not (e.g. look at C# and Java, which have == and Object.Equals() and Equatable, and where collections of equatable items aren't themselves equatable).

But even then, it doesn't really solve the "contains-problem", because the request is ambiguous by the very nature of a collection of references - perhaps you do, in fact, want to check if a reference to an object is present in the collection or not, rather than checking for something that is value-equal. This also goes for comparing whole collections for equality element-by-element etc. All those cases, at the minimum, need a way for the caller to specify which kind of comparison they need. Worse yet, there's no clear default here - both are common - so, ideally, it should always be explicit.

There are no comments on this comment yet.