Re:My Opinion on “5” == 5
by egeozcan on Thursday July 29, 2021 @01:12PM
(#27998789)
That historical... erm... glitch... in C# is very unfortunate and burned us many times back when I was working in a .NET shop (people getting creative was usually the culprit). I've even seen some codebases where people decided to implement their own equality operators (lesson through experience: don't do this).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
They picked that up from C++
They picked it up from Java, which also used == to mean both reference equality and value equality.
But C# also tried to improve on Java. One of the things that the latter was commonly criticized for, was the need to use .equals() for strings for value comparisons - which is almost always what you want - and avoiding the more obvious ==. So they overloaded == for strings to mean value equality, while retaining them as reference types.
IMO, the bigger mistake here was to keep strings as reference types - they really ought to be value types (the implementation can still wrap a reference to the actual string data internally, and share it between copies, but the client shouldn't be able to observe that).