Re:Short array syntax finally in PHP 5.4
by barredo on Sunday July 24, 2011 @10:23AM
(#2799426)
Now if only when a function returns an array we needn't a variable...
[ Parent
| on HN ]
http://svn.php.net/viewvc?view=revision&revision=300266
http://www.php.net/archive/2011.php#id2011-06-28-1
It's in PHP 5.4 alpha as well ;)
Thanks!
It's not quite what you're asking for, but there is a way to handle array results from functions where you know the number of elements that will be returned.
For example:
// explode splits the string on the provided boundary
// and returns an array containing each segment.
// using list() we can assign the two segments to two
// variables within the same statement
$size = "1000x1000";
list( $width, $height ) = explode( "x", $size );
Ah yes, I love nothing more than functions on the left side of assignment.
Edit: Yes, it is a special form, but its still irregular, and that makes it shitty.
http://www.php.net/manual/en/function.list.php
It's a language construct, not a function.
It's a pretty common feature of a lot of languages (Python, Perl, etc) so it's really not that irregular.
It looks more obviously "language feature" in Perl, Python, and JavaScript, though:
my ($foo, $bar) = f;
(foo, bar) = f()
var [foo, bar] = f();How are any of those examples significantly different from:
list($foo, $bar) = f();
Given that PHP uses the array() keyword for constructing arrays, it is perfectly symmetrical. My IDE highlights the list() keyword just the same as all the other keywords.`list` is a special form, not a function.
Re:Short array syntax finally in PHP 5.4
by joelhaasnoot on Sunday July 24, 2011 @10:28AM
(#2799431)
Especially since you can do $a->b->c->d
I don't see how this will ever be useful. The state "echo boo()[1];" assumes you're only ever going to need that one value from the array. The rest of the array is lost. What if the next line in the code needs index 3 from the array? Now you have to run the function again.
I also don't agree that PHP needs constructors to return $this for the same reason. You need to assign the object to a variable so you can reuse it.
$a = new Foo()->bar();
In this case if I later want to call another method on the Foo instance I have recreate it.you're assuming that cases don't exist where you won't reuse something. this is a false assumption, e.g. if all I wanted was the creation date of a file: stat("filepath")[7] is a reasonable way to do this in php, but you can't currently.