In the above video Andrej Karpathy claims that LIDAR required previously compiled maps, the creation of which is not scalable. Do you disagree with that point of view?
Without the maps, you'd need to rely pretty heavily on vision to do the right thing.
What LIDAR gives you is a very accurate point cloud to work from. You can get a point cloud from vision (and indeed, that's what telsa is doing) but it won't be near as accurate as LIDAR is by default.
Lidar would be able to tell you if the object should even be evaluated.
A light hanging from a cable would still get a lidar ping back. The moon would be a void with no lidar ping.
Maybe is not acceptable (and blind in the rain/fog), so you must rely on vision to make the decision – which is why Tesla goes straight to the heart of the problem.
They haven't solved it yet, obviously, but neither has Waymo or anyone else. Tesla is probably collecting more images of 'moon or traffic light?' images than the rest of the industry combined already.
You'd be able to tell there's no object anywhere near the car and disregard the light.