News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Skin-Deep Correctness Isn't, and Foundations Matter by mycroftiv on Sunday July 24, 2011 @12:13AM (#2798600)
I've been reading this blog intermittently for quite a long time, and despite a lot of good conceptual thinking, I believe the author fails to understand a lot of principles which are equally important to the ones that he espouses. Maybe the most important is independence of layers - the author seems convinced that, as he says in this post, "it is the bedrock abstractions of a system which create its overall flavor. They are the ultimate constraints on the range of thinkable thoughts for designer and user alike."

I think this is simply wrong. Certainly, abstractions tend to leak, but the loper-os guy thinks that you can't create a usable system unless you extend lisp-like concepts all the way down to the CPU designs. He never seems to acknowledge that technologies like virtualization actually work to create independent environments.

Re:Why Skin-Deep Correctness Isn't, and Foundations Matter by asciilifeform on Sunday July 24, 2011 @11:03AM (#2799497)
> He never seems to acknowledge that technologies like virtualization actually work to create independent environments.

This is because they don't.

Environments can be independent in the information-security sense (what you and others confuse with full conceptual independence) without being independent in the propagation-of-brokenness sense. Easy example: your power supply.

Give me, say, a Common Lisp (rather low bar!) environment which is entirely uninfluenced by the brokenness of x86. [1] Then we'll talk about independence of layers.

When the last idiot talking about static languages being "inherently efficient" has vanished, then we'll talk about independence of layers.

--

[1] For instance: the fact that you need threads at all. On a dataflow architecture, threads and their attendant idiocies - locking, race conditions, etc. are forgotten like a bad dream.

Re:Why Skin-Deep Correctness Isn't, and Foundations Matter by MrJagil on Sunday July 24, 2011 @11:38AM (#2799560)
Stop calling people idiots.
Re:Why Skin-Deep Correctness Isn't, and Foundations Matter by asciilifeform on Sunday July 24, 2011 @12:19PM (#2799671)
Stop telling people to stop calling idiots idiots.