Re:Ask HN: why so critical?
by badclient on Saturday July 23, 2011 @04:26PM
(#2797727)
That's the part about HN that I actually like. For the most part, the top neg posts in threads are thoughtful and provide a different perspective with value.
Not to mention in many occasions, I don't even think the OP has any specific opinion of the issue at debate; he is merely pointing out counterarguments to consider. I find it very helpful to evaluate counterarguments as a means to strengthening or modifying your original arguments.
That is far different from "no, you wrong!" type of comments found elsewhere on the web.
Not to mention in many occasions, I don't even think the OP has any specific opinion of the issue at debate; he is merely pointing out counterarguments to consider. I find it very helpful to evaluate counterarguments as a means to strengthening or modifying your original arguments.
That is far different from "no, you wrong!" type of comments found elsewhere on the web.