Re:Cyber Insurance Incident Response: Market tends towards c...
by tptacek on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:14PM
(#27966157)
Just for additional context: until around 2016, there was a FedRAMP requirement that services be run on DNSSEC-signed zones. They rescinded that requirement --- they tried mandating DNSSEC and decided, you know what? nah.
Two other big industry-wide things that happened vis a vis DNSSEC:
1. All the mail providers banded together and came up with an alternate SMTP transport security standard, MTA-STS, that says explicitly that it exists because nobody wants to deploy DNSSEC.
2. The DNSSEC people and the browser/TLS people got together and proposed a DNSSEC stapling mechanism as a TLS extension. That stapling --- which Geoff Huston once wrote was an existentially important feature for DNSSEC, since DNSSEC queries routinely fail when made behind random CPE equipment that won't forward weird-looking DNS messages --- failed and was withdrawn.
There are basically no positive signals with respect to DNSSEC deployment. We're belaboring it; your comment isn't really about DNSSEC. I'm just saying: even if you're very, very diligent about security, it's unlikely that DNSSEC would be a high priority item. :)
Two other big industry-wide things that happened vis a vis DNSSEC:
1. All the mail providers banded together and came up with an alternate SMTP transport security standard, MTA-STS, that says explicitly that it exists because nobody wants to deploy DNSSEC.
2. The DNSSEC people and the browser/TLS people got together and proposed a DNSSEC stapling mechanism as a TLS extension. That stapling --- which Geoff Huston once wrote was an existentially important feature for DNSSEC, since DNSSEC queries routinely fail when made behind random CPE equipment that won't forward weird-looking DNS messages --- failed and was withdrawn.
There are basically no positive signals with respect to DNSSEC deployment. We're belaboring it; your comment isn't really about DNSSEC. I'm just saying: even if you're very, very diligent about security, it's unlikely that DNSSEC would be a high priority item. :)