Re:Police are telling ShotSpotter to alter evidence from gun...
by dragonwriter on Monday July 26, 2021 @01:46PM
(#27962551)
> The police have resisted incremental reforms,
That's not really the problem. Even where the police have embraced incremental reforms they've driven funding and responsibility into the police, pushing them into more domains for which they are inappropriate, and haven't dealt with the underlying problems because those aren't peripheral policy problems but fundamental structural problems of having a general purpose paramilitary force as a top level local government organization unto which almost all law enforcement and some peripheral tasks are layered fostering an insular warrior culture without any other strong focus. (Note that when the US was founded—before standing paramilitary domestic security forces were common enough to be a particular general concern—avoiding a very similar problem with military forces which inevitably would get leaned on for domestic security was a major reason for skepticism of standing armies in favor of relying on militia + cadre, and thus for the second amendment.)
Which also suggests what the “something else” to replace the police could be—given that abandoning professional permanent law enforcement for reliance on citizen militia/posses is probably not viable for modern society, one way to address that problem is to have specialized law enforcement entities in domain-specific agencies whose individual foci are narrower, enabling each to have a cultural focus (and substantive competence requirements) that are domain specific.
And if you look at US law enforcement beyond the local level, that's what a lot of it looks like already. The highly centralized paramilitary law enforcement structure where the top uniformed commander is a the head of a top level agency of the unit of government (and possibly independently elected and effectively unaccountable to the civilian government officials) is unique to city/county government.
That's not really the problem. Even where the police have embraced incremental reforms they've driven funding and responsibility into the police, pushing them into more domains for which they are inappropriate, and haven't dealt with the underlying problems because those aren't peripheral policy problems but fundamental structural problems of having a general purpose paramilitary force as a top level local government organization unto which almost all law enforcement and some peripheral tasks are layered fostering an insular warrior culture without any other strong focus. (Note that when the US was founded—before standing paramilitary domestic security forces were common enough to be a particular general concern—avoiding a very similar problem with military forces which inevitably would get leaned on for domestic security was a major reason for skepticism of standing armies in favor of relying on militia + cadre, and thus for the second amendment.)
Which also suggests what the “something else” to replace the police could be—given that abandoning professional permanent law enforcement for reliance on citizen militia/posses is probably not viable for modern society, one way to address that problem is to have specialized law enforcement entities in domain-specific agencies whose individual foci are narrower, enabling each to have a cultural focus (and substantive competence requirements) that are domain specific.
And if you look at US law enforcement beyond the local level, that's what a lot of it looks like already. The highly centralized paramilitary law enforcement structure where the top uniformed commander is a the head of a top level agency of the unit of government (and possibly independently elected and effectively unaccountable to the civilian government officials) is unique to city/county government.