News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Signal on Android: Images sent to wrong contacts by tablespoon on Sunday July 25, 2021 @03:36PM (#27952222)
> How can users be assured that this type of issue won't occur again?

By not using software.

And I mean software in general, not this software in particular. You're basically asking for assurance that they won't have any more bugs, but no one can actually provide such an assurance in the real world.

Re:Signal on Android: Images sent to wrong contacts by stathibus on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:27PM (#27955268)
Yes, they can.
Re:Signal on Android: Images sent to wrong contacts by tablespoon on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:36AM (#27955717)
> Yes, they can.

If they do, they're either incompetent, lying, or building something enormously expensive yet completely impractical for most if not all real world uses.

Re:Signal on Android: Images sent to wrong contacts by stathibus on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:09AM (#27957649)
I don't understand this attitude. Where did we go wrong as a discipline where making products that actually work is such an outlandish proposition? No other consumer product industry would talk like this.
Re:Signal on Android: Images sent to wrong contacts by aeturnum on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:06PM (#27961151)
It comes from the halting problem. People can be more careful writing code, but it is impossible to be certain about all the things code will or won't do. Even very simple programs can have flaws that get found and fixed years later. It happens all the time.

We need to be open and honest about the possibility that our code may act in ways we don't foresee.

Re:Signal on Android: Images sent to wrong contacts by stathibus on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:51PM (#27961750)
If this was actually true, we wouldn't have safety critical software systems that have been running for decades without fatal bugs.
Re:Signal on Android: Images sent to wrong contacts by tablespoon on Monday July 26, 2021 @03:40PM (#27964358)
> If this was actually true, we wouldn't have safety critical software systems that have been running for decades without fatal bugs.

Not hitting a bug is not the same as not having a bug. I'd bet money that whatever system you're talking about has bugs. Plus, the system may be far simpler than you assume.

Re:Signal on Android: Images sent to wrong contacts by tablespoon on Monday July 26, 2021 @10:48AM (#27960061)
> I don't understand this attitude. Where did we go wrong as a discipline where making products that actually work is such an outlandish proposition? No other consumer product industry would talk like this.

Part of it is cost/benefit ratio for the extra effort, part of it is market demands, part of it is lack of technology, part of it is unavoidable stuff like the halting problem.

It's also worth remembering that Signal is developed by a non-profit with a total of 36 staff members (if Wikipedia is correct). That means they have fewer developers, and even fewer Android developers.

Re:Signal on Android: Images sent to wrong contacts by stathibus on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:50PM (#27961733)
This is a messaging app we're talking about here. There's nothing outrageously difficult or complex that hasn't already been done 25 years ago. If 36 people and $100 million in funding is not enough to make a messaging app that doesn't suck, what _is_ required and why is it more than that?
Re:Signal on Android: Images sent to wrong contacts by tablespoon on Monday July 26, 2021 @03:31PM (#27964221)
> This is a messaging app we're talking about here. There's nothing outrageously difficult or complex that hasn't already been done 25 years ago.

If you think it's so easy, be your own change and do it, and then we can judge the results.

> If 36 people and $100 million in funding is not enough to make a messaging app that doesn't suck, what _is_ required and why is it more than that?

You're assuming there's a solution of a certain form to get you what you want, but maybe it's your assumption that's wrong.

I mean, there are formally verified systems that might be like what you're asking, but they're both 1) very expensive, 2) extremely feature poor.

Re:Signal on Android: Images sent to wrong contacts by stathibus on Monday July 26, 2021 @08:55PM (#27967401)
I'm busy, but tell you what, I'll do it for only $75 million. Maybe I should launch a Kickstarter.
Re:Signal on Android: Images sent to wrong contacts by lwhi on Sunday July 25, 2021 @04:27PM (#27952631)
I disagree. If that really is the choice, they should drop the secure moniker without further debate.

--

If you produce a product that claims to be secure, the onus is on you to back up those claims.

Off the top my my head there are many ways to implement measures that can help to encourage security going forward.

One of the benefits of coding in the open, and ascribing to opens standards and protocols is transparency and the ability for all to interrogate the code.

Can that work? It's obviously partly also down to the culture of the product team. As another poster in this thread has highlighted, the commit messages are terse and not as helpful as they could be. Perhaps more openness re. intention would help.

Also, why are we finding out about this bug over 7 months after it was reported? Transparency regarding vulnerabilities needs to be at the forefront of the products communications if the team really are serious about security.

In terms of isolating bugs; what kind of testing is in place. TDD, functional testing, beta testing?

There are so many avenues which _could_ be discussed in relation to my initial question.

Your response, is unfortunately not providing anything helpful.

Re:Signal on Android: Images sent to wrong contacts by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday July 25, 2021 @04:50PM (#27952798)
> One of the benefits of coding in the open, and ascribing to opens standards and protocols is transparency and the ability for all to interrogate the code.

They already do all of those things. https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Android

Re:Signal on Android: Images sent to wrong contacts by hellcow on Sunday July 25, 2021 @05:47PM (#27953222)
In word but not in spirit. They stopped updating their repo for an entire year while integrating a crypto shitcoin in secret.

These actions betray trust, and trust is Signal's entire reason for being.

Re:Signal on Android: Images sent to wrong contacts by lwhi on Sunday July 25, 2021 @06:52PM (#27953697)
You need to reread my post.

The situation is far more complicated than your link to the GitHub repo would indicate.