Re:Using Benford’s Law to Detect Bitcoin Manipulation
by fluidcruft on Sunday July 25, 2021 @09:08AM
(#27948911)
I don't really know anything about this but every time I read these analyses using Benford's Law I don't understand why anyone would expect Bitcoin's exchange rate to begin with the digit "1" ~30% of the time. Once you're not talking about human-guestimated numbers, it seems more like a question of scale factors. If bitcoin's value fluctuates between 30k and 70k it's never going to start with a "1". Or if its value fluctuates between 120k and 180k then it's always going to start with "1". That's where I struggle trying to understand how Benford's Law is supposed to provide any insight.
Re:Using Benford’s Law to Detect Bitcoin Manipulation
by FabHK on Sunday July 25, 2021 @12:43PM
(#27950610)
Benford's law tends to fit better when:
* the numbers span many orders of magnitude
* the numbers are produced by multiplication (where log(x) is normal-ish), not addition (where x is normal-ish)
Your examples span half an order of magnitude, so it definitely doesn't apply (as you say).
Re:Using Benford’s Law to Detect Bitcoin Manipulation
by y04nn on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:51AM
(#27950059)
Yes, I don't know if the prices should have a better Benford's Law fit when the price is around and 10k or 100k but then a lesser fit when the price is between 5/50k and 9k/99k if you have not enough data. But if there is enough data, maybe it should better fit the Benford's Law, and this may be a proof that arround 10k/20k the price was rigged and should have stay around it longer but manipulation put it around 30k/50k.
Re:Using Benford’s Law to Detect Bitcoin Manipulation
by x4e on Sunday July 25, 2021 @11:19AM
(#27949761)
I believe it’s about which numbers it ends with, not starts with
Re:Using Benford’s Law to Detect Bitcoin Manipulation
by dannyw on Sunday July 25, 2021 @06:59AM
(#27948261)
Correct. I've been in the bitcoin space for a decade now, and there were only brief moments* where it was difficult to buy or sell at the price quoted by major exchanges.
* DDoS attacks, exchange illiquidity, etc.
Plus, even if Bitcoin's price is mainly a product of manipulation -- speculators trying to make the price rise or fall relative to where it is right now -- there's no reason we can't think of that as also being a random process which produces some statistical distribution.
Benford's law works for detecting fraud because the process that humans use to choose random numbers -- just write down a bunch of random digits -- results in a statistical distribution that is unusual relative to what would be produced by a natural process. But it seems quite unlikely to me that Bitcoin price manipulation takes the form of a whale saying "OK, I just wrote down a bunch of random digits, this is our BTC price target for Wednesday".