Re:CO₂ Coin: Decentralized Carbon Capture Blockchains (2021)
by endisneigh on Saturday July 24, 2021 @07:43PM
(#27945346)
Your smart contract proposal doesn't contradict my concerns about immutability. What if the contract is improperly written or does the wrong thing? What would be done then? A smart contract isn't magic. So again I'm not really sure what your point is?
Is it that if everything goes perfectly with smart contracts being written perfectly with no bugs and all contingencies being taken into account and participants of the contract agree to the terms of said smart contracts in the event of fraud that's identified and confirmed it can be reversed? OK, point understood.
But to your point that it's possible to hard fork, well, of course, computers being turing complete you can always go one level deeper into the platform and change the underlying system, but on a practical level forcing all of the miners to upgrade their software and coordinating this is a HUGE effort, and it seems like a very bad architectural decision to force an entire platform upgrade to deal with fraudulent users when safety can be built into the smart contracts themselves.
But I'm not arguing this centralisation is a good idea either, I'm merely pointing out that immutability isn't as final as the original post would make it seem, and there are ways of dealing with the problems they outlined (someone having fraudulently acquired tokens)