for example: https://youtu.be/damkjiFNn5E
Caroline Herschel Telescope would be cool, she mapped the skies so it feels appropriate
The four astronomers leading the renaming petition say that when Webb worked for the state department in the high-ranking position of undersecretary from 1949 to 1952, he passed a set of memos discussing what was described as “the problem of homosexuals and sex perverts” to a senator who was leading the persecution.
will edit it, thanks for the correction
The problem is not the lack of spotless characters. There is no such thing. The problem is the permanently outraged.
It’s like we assume that whatever they died believing they’d still believe today. I’m highly skeptical of that. Culture changes over time and people along with it. Except these people don’t have that opportunity to clarify or revisit their views because they’re dead.
He's alive and when he dies will have his reputation intact. Had he died while being negative about gay people by current social mores he would have his views frozen for all time.
Separately, also never underestimate people's life experiences shaping their views. We can all learn from events in other people's lives that shaped their perspective. Not healthy to rinse that away.
What you’re defending is James Webb’s immaculate memory. Please think long and hard about whether it’s worth defending the immaculate memory of anyone.
Erasing is when there's something written somewhere, and then it's erased. So if you started with your name on something and ended without your name on something, that'd be an example of erasing your name.
Additionally, think of some currently-benign things you regularly do today, that will be taboo in 30 years (hint: There's no way to know). All a future canceler has to do is trawl through your history and find all the things that you did or said today that are considered offensive in 2041.
You are trying to conflate not glorifying someone with erasing them from history.
They two completely different things.
If anything, glorification of individuals blurs the lines between objective historical memory and moral judgement.
I'm LGBT and I'm not impacted by whether or not James Webb had straight Christian biases. Everyone of that era did.
Galileo and Newton would have been pretty trash by today's standards. I'd even bet Einstein might've harbored prejudices despite going through what he did. It was the zeitgeist.
Apollo and the old gods were pretty devious. Orion, who we're still naming things after, was a rapist in some stories. Where's the outrage for these cartoon characters?
If we keep doing this, we need to rename America itself. Because Amerigo Vespucci isn't clean. And then where does it stop?
History is fucked up. 20,000 years ago we all ate one another, and I'm not going to cry about it. Looking at the animal kingdom, we've come a long way. I'd hate to be game for a lion on the savannah. Or a Neanderthal snack. Past mistakes and evolution made us stronger, and there are too many problems on the horizon to fixate on trying to clean up and play pretend. Forgetting our past also weakens the muscles we had to develop in the first place.
Are we going to strip George Washington from all the monuments, too? I think the better idea is to teach the history so that we're kinder and more mindful. This project has been known as James Webb since its inception, and it's busywork and posturing to change it.
I'm LGBT, and frankly, I'm mad at this. I overwhelmingly get the sense that a group of people that I don't relate to very well are looking for targets to blame that conflict with their identity. I increasingly find myself less and less tied to a shared identity with these people and compelled to strong sense of individualism.
James Webb doesn't exist anymore. The language token embeddings of his name call back history and the role he had in early NASA. I'm not going to blame him for anything. In fact, now I want to know more about him to enrich my understanding.
I'm usually pretty liberal. I know my opinion on this issue isn't popular, but this is something that directly touches me. I'm an individual and I'm interested more in history than empty placating.
I'm sure whatever LGBT person we rename the telescope after will be culturally significant. Maybe my problem is just that _I_ want to be the LGBT person that people in the future look up to for my hopefully future merits and accomplishments. I don't need to be told to look up to some dug up idol. I'm too busy looking forward instead of behind.
We need to have a serious think about the value of erasing historical figures based on their actions in a very different past.
I know people who were bigots in the past but have substantially changed their perspective, and I also know people who have become more rigid and bigoted in their views over time. One of those people is gay fwiw.
Why is it that perceived character flaws based on current social mores result in historical people being cancelled in our current climate? Rinsing out perceived offensive behaviors from history will surely lead to a future featuring a bland lack of knowledge and no real world behavioral social frameworks