News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge criticizes Google and Oracle at hearing by nl on Thursday July 21, 2011 @09:57PM (#2792076)
The title (here "It appears Google will amost certainly have to pay something to Oracle") is totally wrong.

This is about the parties disagreeing what damages might apply if Google is found guilty. That is by no means certain, and this article doesn't address that issue at all.

It would be extremely unusual if the amount to come out of this phase of the case was $0, but Google is using that to put an argument for a low figure.

Re:Judge criticizes Google and Oracle at hearing by latch on Thursday July 21, 2011 @10:14PM (#2792119)

  but Google is using that to put an argument for a low figure.
And pissing off the judge by making stupid claims. Negotiating isn't about starting at the lowest number, it's about starting at the lowest _reasonable_ number. Anything else and you just antagonize people (which Google apparently did)
Re:Judge criticizes Google and Oracle at hearing by nl on Thursday July 21, 2011 @11:24PM (#2792292)
And pissing off the judge by making stupid claims

Yeah, this is true. But Google needs to establish their position to the court as being "we don't make any direct revenue off Android".

The whole judge being pissed off is really just theatre. I'm sure the judge expected this, and his anger is more about speeding up the process than anything.

And don't forget the Judge is just as annoyed at Oracle's claims as Google's.

Re:Judge criticizes Google and Oracle at hearing by blinkingled on Thursday July 21, 2011 @11:13PM (#2792258)
To be fair to Google - doesn't the fact that they even agree to any damages weaken their case? I don't understand why they would have to determine damages before investigating if they infringed or not.

Going with Java and not buying Sun was HUGE mistake on Google's part - major strategic gaffe. You can thank Mark Hurd for the fact that HP did not buy Sun - even then Google would be better off as HP has no history of suing people left and right.

Re:Judge criticizes Google and Oracle at hearing by tzs on Friday July 22, 2011 @01:38AM (#2792558)
In a patent case, the plaintiff puts forth two arguments for the jury:

1. The defendant infringes the patent.

2. The damages for said infringement should be $X.

The defendant will put forth three arguments:

1. Plaintiff doesn't even have a valid patent. This is really several arguments, directed at pretty much everything that plaintiff must have done for their patent to be valid and theirs.

2. Defendant does not infringe the patent.

3. IF they did infringe the patent, the plaintiff's damage numbers are nuts and the correct damages would be $Y (which is much smaller than $X).

To make their damage arguments, both sides bring in experts on damages, who write reports which are submitted to the court, and then the experts testify about these reports in front of the jury. Before the trial starts, both sides challenge the qualifications of the other side's damages expert, trying to convince the court he's a quack and the court should throw out his report and make the other side offer a reasonable damage theory. That's about the stage they are at now.