Yes. Price competition is a wonderful thing. They undercut IBM's pricing model. IBM tried to get it back with the PS/2, which was patent protected. But that totally missed the point.
> It's just tragic that the crap SW and HW won the market.
Crap SW and HW made the market. There wasn't much of a market for PCs at the PS/2 price point. There was a much larger market at the PC clone price point. (I'd guess that halving the price led to something like 10 times the volume. The PS/2 was locked out of any meaningful volume just by the price.)
General rule: The PC I can afford is better than the PC I can't. Sure, it may be technically inferior. Doesn't matter. The one I can't afford has zero utility for me, so the one I can afford is actually better (for me), no matter how crap it is.
The other thing that made that market was the clone vendors cooperating to define the EISA bus standard. It created a huge market (all the clone companies put together) for peripherals. And because you could get anything in an EISA peripheral, that created a huge market for EISA PCs. It was mutually reinforcing to create an exploding market. If they had fought each other with competing bus standards, that would have killed the market.
From that perspective, all the clone makers really did was being intelligently lazy. They just built IBM 5170s with faster CPUs for years. It was probably MORE effort to develop a custom bus and break all the existing expansion options. You saw some brief experimentation with that for the early "local bus" machines before the advent of VL-Bus, but that was quite a few years after the debut of MCA and ISA had legitimately run out of gas.
EISA might have been important from the perspective of building a vendor-neutral standards process.
The article's claim about "IBM’s strategic error in not retaining rights to the operating system" begs the question if the PC revolution would have happened had Microsoft not owned it. I personally doubt it. While IBM had success up to the IBM AT, there really wasn't much revolutionary about them and they were stupidly expensive. The clones really made the PC a success. It's just tragic that the crap SW and HW won the market.