Re:33GB of public domain JSTOR articles, and a manifesto
by impendia on Thursday July 21, 2011 @02:13PM
(#2790574)
I work at a university. I don't think universities have any vested interest in maintaining their place of privilege. Certainly faculty members don't, with rare exceptions (at least one of which I know about).
But I think there is not a lot of interest in changing the system. The people who could change things are not directly affected by the disadvantages of the current system.
Re:33GB of public domain JSTOR articles, and a manifesto
by coliveira on Thursday July 21, 2011 @03:44PM
(#2790966)
The issue is, university professors already have access to these papers. They are among the few people that want, need, and can understand the science behind it. It looks like it makes sense that universities are willing to pay for that privilege.
Re:33GB of public domain JSTOR articles, and a manifesto
by pnathan on Thursday July 21, 2011 @04:37PM
(#2791184)
You forgot larger industrial research lab-y companies, e.g., Google and DuPont.
Re:33GB of public domain JSTOR articles, and a manifesto
by lotu on Thursday July 21, 2011 @02:04PM
(#2790538)
We have services like youtube and Flicker that provide hosting for movies and pictures for free. The data requirements are far greater for these services than they would be for an academic journal hosting. If you didn't want to go the centralized method a small journal with under 1,000 readers (>10MB per month per user) could probably host buy hosting for under $100/year. Something that small would be easy to cover out of pocket or via donations
Re:33GB of public domain JSTOR articles, and a manifesto
by jcarreiro on Thursday July 21, 2011 @03:21PM
(#2790878)
> We have services like youtube and Flicker that provide hosting for movies and pictures for free. The data requirements are far greater for these
Don't be so sure. Some experiments can produce large data sets, which ideally should be made available alongside the published paper.
Academic journals are full of incredibly specific knowledge. While some of it is accessible to people with a moderate amount of intelligence/diligence, any journal whose name isn't "Science" is designed for and by an incredibly small group of individuals with an incredibly specific knowledge base. Where is the donor base for that?
Answer: Universities are the only plausible donors. And they seem to think maintaining their place of privilege in being able to access the articles is worth some extra bucks.