Re:A pound of flesh: how Cisco's "unmitigated gall" derailed...
by prospero on Thursday July 21, 2011 @12:32PM
(#2790151)
"It's what I had to do to keep my job" isn't some sort of cure-all justification for unethical/criminal behavior.
Re:A pound of flesh: how Cisco's "unmitigated gall" derailed...
by Produce on Thursday July 21, 2011 @12:39PM
(#2790180)
That was the point I was trying to make :) OP suggested that whoever made the decision should face criminal liability. I said that all the other people involved should face it too.
Re:A pound of flesh: how Cisco's "unmitigated gall" derailed...
by chc on Thursday July 21, 2011 @12:53PM
(#2790226)
I know that somebody is going to starve to death in Africa today. I am not going to fly to Africa, track them down and stop it. That does not make me morally equal to a back-alley mugger. There are different degrees of volition and complicity.
Re:A pound of flesh: how Cisco's "unmitigated gall" derailed...
by true_religion on Thursday July 21, 2011 @02:34PM
(#2790661)
That isn't an argument against what he said.
He said that all those involved should be charged. You're giving an example of vague knowledge without involvement.
Re:A pound of flesh: how Cisco's "unmitigated gall" derailed...
by jackpirate on Thursday July 21, 2011 @07:58PM
(#2791815)
It is possible that no individual person knew the full scope of what was happening. What is needed is anytime a company pursues legal action is a line from the CEO (or delegate) saying they are fully aware of the details of this case and take personal responsibility for its correctness.
Re:A pound of flesh: how Cisco's "unmitigated gall" derailed...
by wnight on Friday July 22, 2011 @06:47PM
(#2795464)
What is needed is to charge the company directly as well as any specific people. Nothing should happen without oversight and that's the company's responsibility, in the way a warranty return is the company's, not the mailroom guy's, responsibility.
The discussion is a bit like the Chinese-Room thought experiment. Would you charge the worker if the manual on deciphering Chinese was actually a manual on running a Ponzi scheme in Chinese? In some hypotheses it might be unclear to the workers that the process is ultimately unjust, but practically (speaking as someone who's been (briefly) employed at a few shady companies), intentional ignorance of their effects, and usually an attitude that the customer deserved it for not knowing better, are pervasive from customer service up to management.
EDIT: What, exactly, do you all disagree with?