1. Engineering is a lot more personal and creative than we think
2. A large amount of software development is very similar to trad engineering
3. Never walk over a bridge.Here’s the kicker though: The part that is done by compilers used to be the bulk of software engineering.
In his Art and Science book Hamming talks about how programmers rejected the idea of even just automated address assignment. They took great pride in manually managing absolute addressing. Only a sissy who doesn’t know real programming would ever use something so silly as symbolic addressing, to say nothing of compiling from assembly. Ugh!
Now we don’t even think about that. Too boring, too solved, too uncreative.
There is a lot of engineering that we currently do, which is completely mechanical, mindless, and can be automated away.
* We create new technology.
* There's an explosion of creativity and applications of the technology.
* This leads to an explosion in the personalities involved.
* Some of these gravitate towards the tedium and expound on it constantly.
* Some person or group automates that away and increases the ability to be creative.
* Repeat from the top.
It's always fun to watch the wheel go around though. Never any shortage of commentary on HN about it!
I think of it this way: what would a CRC manual[1] for software engineering comprise?
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CRC_Handbook_of_Chemistry_and_...
In good conditions, yes, the drudgery is all done by the compiler. There's still a terrifying number of cases where something hasn't been automated and still qualifies as factory work.
Where actual enineering disciplines has the risk of removing the creative part.
I think this classification is wrong. There IS NO mindless factory-work.
Just as in other enineering disciplines, our work is not manufacturing. It's just that the actual manufacturing does not exist (or rather is done by compiler)
Software enineering can (just like other enineering) be:
without removing the creativity.Just as "other" enineering (like software):
I REALLY feel we can mature in SWE without being afraid of losing creativity.