News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Your idea is brilliant, your idea is worthless (2016) by h2odragon on Tuesday July 20, 2021 @11:17AM (#27894791)
I had the joyous experience of not just having someone else implement my idea (they didn't steal it, it wasn't that original); but having their implementation be in all ways better than I'd imagined making. Theirs was great. And flopped utterly. I heard they dumped something like $500k and a year into it, where my utter failure only took a couple weeks. :)

Apparently me and the person at their ship behind that project were the only people in the world interested in the idea.

Re:Your idea is brilliant, your idea is worthless (2016) by tunesmith on Tuesday July 20, 2021 @09:09PM (#27901157)
I had the experience of implementing an idea successfully. I had a lot of fun with it, it had a degree of popularity, and then one of my community's members went off an implemented the exact same thing on a competing website.

Mine was just a hobby and was never going to make money. What was fun about it was that it was original, and I was the only person doing it, and it had a fun little community and it got some press, too. It was rewarding in a social sense, a fun hobby.

That other guy probably thought there might have been a little bit of commercial benefit to it, or SEO benefit. He launched his site - the same system, just "his" instead of mine. It seemed like the community started getting quiet - they felt awkward about the new site since he was a prior community member. The whole experience soured me on the idea and I started losing interest too.

I eventually took my site down. His site is still going and he's since updated it to generate its content automatically, but it appears to get zero traffic, and has zero community. It's a weird feeing, kind of like being replaced by something soulless.

I don't know what my point is - you could definitely argue that that's just the way it goes sometimes, that I got some fun out of it, and people are always free to try and implement the same thing you do, it's not like I had a patent. But I also feel like the other site contributed to me losing motivation to keep mine going as a hobby, and his site didn't go anywhere either, so overall it feels like a net negative to whatever tiny bit of culture was living at that time.

Re:Your idea is brilliant, your idea is worthless (2016) by spfzero on Wednesday July 21, 2021 @01:11AM (#27902551)
Totally feel for you. You bumped into a bad apple. Please know that those are rare, and don’t be discouraged from going at it again. If you did it once, you can do it again, and most likely won’t run into a parasitic community member often.
Re:Your idea is brilliant, your idea is worthless (2016) by sircastor on Tuesday July 20, 2021 @04:24PM (#27898818)
Are you willing to share what it was? You’ve piqued my interest.
Re:Your idea is brilliant, your idea is worthless (2016) by h2odragon on Tuesday July 20, 2021 @05:07PM (#27899352)
Had to do with bringing a large but simple database to a web interface for potential public perusal. At the time me and my surplus sparcs were bidding $5/record for this (billions of records total in the real job), where the "professional estimates" were 10x that. I had a demo of the full dataset, the other effort was using a 1/20th subset.

The problem was no one actually cared to look at that data, which kindof made the entire thing moot. The data itself had to do with government spending; which added layers of bullshit that I tried to avoid even hearing of.