Be a rock. This doesn't mean be hard-headed and unpersuadable, but it also means not being lead around by statistics and citations and "studies". Know who you are, trust your instincts, and do what is right for you.
The fact is, unless you're actually the scientist doing the science, almost all the papers and publishing and Science The Meme! that happens and is constantly and endlessly touted, has zero bearing on your own personal life. Ignore it all.
In particular, when it comes to health science, you can literally ignore every little bit of it--none of that garbage gets in front of a wide audience unless it's got some profit for some concern at the other end. Know how to feed yourself and stay fit and healthy. Sure, you could use the NYTimes to determine whether a pescetarian diet is superior to a carnivore diet, or whether you should be eating highly-processed factory-produced fake meat and in what quantities, or you could just use your own common sense and your own body to do your own individual science--try carnivorous eating for a month, then vegan, see how you feel.
Be confident and ever-increasingly capable. Become more dangerous every day. Have an anchor that's ties your core values to who you are, however you define that, and let the rest of the masses get socially engineered into believing whatever the hell they want.
Well, okay. I was kinda with you when you were saying you can ignore most health science headlines, but then you seem to change your mind and hint that there must be some way of gaining knowledge about one’s health without science. So how then? Common sense and personal experimentation are only going to get you so far.
Are you seriously saying you can't figure out how to do these things without bullshit "studies"?
Get some weights. Ear high-quality meat. Sleep 8 hours. Tweak as necessary.
That gets 90% of people to ever-increasingly healthy.
You've been totally neutered if you think you need more than that.
Actually it is not the science that is causing this issue. But research in various forms is.
Trusting science is fundamentally different from trusting "scientists".
Trusting science is essentially trusting nature to behave in a regular fashion. But trusting research, done and proclaimed by a bunch of humans is well, trusting human beings. Nothing could be more fundamentally different.
I think adding a "repeatability factor" to researches could help. So if anyone on the planet can replicate a research method, it should have a repeatability factor value of 1. If only a single entity can replicate it, then it should have a value of 0. If some entities can validate it, then it should have a value somewhere in between.
This does not mean that research that have low RF cannot be applied widely. It just that it will have to do additional work to gain the trust of the people.
It only follows common sense that trust in something cannot be mandated. So, measures that are based on low RF value research should NEVER be mandated. No matter what that cost.
And thus I think this can save the corruption and manipulation in the name of science.
Another COVID-related example is masks. At one point early in the pandemic there was messaging that masks were not useful in preventing the spread of COVID in the general public. There were supply chain reasons that probably motivated that message, but I also know virology PhD students that were insistent it was the truth, with papers in hand. At the time there were also papers to suggest the opposite, so one could have a healthy debate on the subject - but at the end of the day I gave my grandparents a small box of masks, because wearing a mask is so low effort I don't see why you wouldn't unless you are truly extremely certain that it's useless.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/protests-and-trump-r...
Just one of MANY stories why BLM protests are so much less risky than, e.g., Trump rallies.
When it was widely rebuked as hypocritical bullshit, they even came up with a crazy way of explaining it away: Now racism was a "public health crisis", all of a sudden. See the google trends: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=r...
Just like how January 6 was an insurrection worthy of months of security state theatrics and proclamations that "white supremacy" is the biggest threat to the USA domestically, whereas an entire summer of burning buildings and riots was "mostly peaceful protests".
This is why nobody trusts authority and the media anymore--they have given up on even a pretense of seeming trustworthy.
Yes - and it’s not true - there is plenty of footage of protesters not following health guidelines, and indeed plenty of discussion of how the protests may have precipitated a covid spike.
The fact that other similar events were not permitted proves the hypocrisy in the public health guidance regardless of the outcome.
If you don’t think there is any political bias in public health policy, that’s fine, but it seems like we are in disagreement about that.
This is a significant altering of the goal posts. But anyway, you seem convinced it's all part of some huge partisan battle where you're sure that your side is the good side and everything is stacked against your side. I'm not part of this battle.
Not really - it’s a matter of degree. When there is too much bias displayed, it stops being public health and is discredited.
> you seem convinced it's all part of some huge partisan battle where you're sure that your side is the good side and everything is stacked against your side.
This seems like pure imagination on your part. I suggest you reread the thread. You’ll see no evidence anything partisan from me.
I simply think that public health officials have undermined trust by politicizing the issues or otherwise distorted their message. I.e. they have ‘discredited’ the field as the other poster said.
> I'm not part of this battle.
Are you sure? You are the only one reading this conversation and seeing a ‘battle’.