For example, Donkey Kong Country, top is from Super Nes, bottom is from GBA. Both enlarged x4.
I’m not referring to differences in overscan settings—I’m just talking about the fact that overscan exists. It’s a setting, but it’s generally not user-configurable on consumer TVs.
Even with TVs that have more accurate overscan, the TVs still have overscan, so you cannot use the entire area. The HUD goes right to the edge of the screen, but the 256×224 area continues past this. My feelings are that it is up to your judgment exactly what the safe area is, but taken for granted that it is smaller than the full picture.
Newer games and systems were still affected by this—the Nintendo 64, Xbox, PlayStation 2, etc. You could not reasonably put your HUD all the way to the edge of the framebuffer on any of these systems. Overscan only died (sort of) with the arrival of LCDs and HDMI.
> Certainly far more than 160 vertical pixels.
Yes, that would be absurd.
I might be wrong, but it seems you are under the impression that a percent of the active display area was used for overscan. That would only occur if the TV was not calibrated correctly. That's the reason hardware manufacturers instructed developers to not put important content too close to the edge of the screen. However, developers absolutely would have assumed most TVs were displaying the active display area accurately, which is why in the 90s most games had HUDs extending to the edge of the active display.
But this is all really beside the point, because if you watch the posted video, you can see countless examples of how GBA developers had to account for the massively reduced vertical resolution. Look at the Super Mario World example - the GBA version is massively zoomed in, greatly reducing the amount of the screen that is visible.
I still agree that the SNES version sounds much better than the GBA version, but people shouldn't think the SNES version sounded like that remix.
Apparently the "OSV" in the track title means "Original Sound Version". TIL!
GBA: https://youtu.be/UlTgFb0qbxQ
SNES: https://youtu.be/_4EjGXRDOH0
edit: They added some interesting didgeridoo-like sound effects to "Forest Frenzy" though
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UlTgFb0qbxQ&t=2191s
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_4EjGXRDOH0&t=3663s
Pretty stark difference, IMO. GBA version sounds shrill, all the note envelopes seem messed up, the variations in emphasis & phrasing in the SNES version are gone, etc. SNES version is also in stereo.
But then I've also never cared for the DKC soundtrack.
Broadly speaking, the GBA is more capable graphically, has a better CPU, more RAM, a simpler interface to the cartridge, and the best GBA games are going to look pretty good compared to SNES games.
However, the SNES has a dedicated programmable DSP for audio, which can play eight sample tracks simultaneously. The GBA just gives you a DAC and the CPU and you do everything there. You could of course try to make up for that by relying more on PCM tracks and leaning on the larger ROM sizes, but that will only take you so far.
Here’s a track from the FFV port to GBA:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lSUWIxn0Ihw
Here’s the original version for SNES (edit: link fixed):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dghlAQDQneU
To my ears, the SNES one is the clear winner and it shows off the capabilities of the DSP—less aliasing noise (that weird crunchy sound you hear on the GBA version), and also has some basic effects (like a little bit of echo).