Re:It's been three years. Stop saying your European visitors...
by anticristi on Friday July 16, 2021 @07:57AM
(#27855354)
MAW: Nevermind, I'll identify users via browser fingerprinting.
GDPR: Browser generated information was ruled personal data and falls under GDPR.
MAW: Just let me stalk on my users without their consent, goddamit!
Re:It's been three years. Stop saying your European visitors...
by drstewart on Friday July 16, 2021 @08:03AM
(#27855407)
>Every time I read about GDPR compliance, it feels like a very well-designed set of guidelines that are easy to follow ... IF you aren't stalking users.
There's a difference between being compliant and being _in compliance_. There's a real cost to the latter. Why should sites that primarily serve non-European readers bother with it? The assumption that they don't because they're all greedily stalking users is a misguided, but popular, cynical take.
Re:It's been three years. Stop saying your European visitors...
by MereInterest on Friday July 16, 2021 @09:29PM
(#27862914)
I'm not sure what the distinction is between the two. Is one of those having a verified system to ensure that you are compliant, while the other is merely being compliant but unprovably so?
--------------
Hypothetical conversation with a Malicious Advertising Website:
MAW: Can I stalk my users without telling them?
GDPR: No, you must have consent to track users.
MAW: So I can assume I have consent because they're using my site?
GDPR: No, the consent must be explicit.
MAW: Got it, I'll put it somewhere in the fine print of the terms of service.
GDPR: Uninformed consent doesn't count. Fine print doesn't count as informing users.
MAW: Okay, so I'll have a banner with an obvious "accept" button and several hidden steps to opt out.
GDPR: Nope, it must be just as easy to retract permission as to grant it. If it's a single step to accept, then it must be a single step to reject.
MAW: In that case I'll have the "reject" button kick them off the site.
GDPR: Consent must be freely given, and having a service be conditional on consent is coercion. Consent to track may only be given as a gift, and not as an exchange.
MAW: WAAAH!! This is so hard!!
---------
Hypothetical conversation with a Non-Malicious Website:
NMW: I don't track any information about visitors to this site, and only serve non-targeted advertisements.
GDPR: Sounds good, go right ahead.
NMW: Say, I want to make a "To-Do List" site. Do I need to warn users that I'm going to remember the to-do items for them?
GDPR: Nope, no issue there. That's necessary for the service to function.
NMW: Huh, this is really simple.