In other words, it's not marginal numbers that matter, it's absolute numbers, and something absolutely has to be done about those numbers.
--
[0]: https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/10/shipping-industry-car...
In a world that has climate change under control, there's for sure going to be a reduction in pollution produced by global shipping, but in the world we live in there's much better places to start than by limiting global shipping.
That said a carbon tax certainly does limit shipping, as some of it will no longer be profitable. Fortunately when doing it with a carbon tax, it just so happens to be the shipping that we shouldn't have been doing in the first place!
Me too, but I've seen multiple businesses go to the wall after spending seven figures on mandated protections - worthwhile protections - that competitors in you-already-know-where didn't. The second best time is now I suppose, but that has had consequences.
Also, reminder that this is proposed to *not* apply to the single most polluting form of transport: https://gript.ie/eu-plans-carbon-tax-for-most-flights-except...
The problem with fuel taxes is that it's hard to tell whether the money is spent toward making everyone less reliant on fuel... or simply funding pensions for underperforming bureaucrats!
Collecting an extra tax on a single mother of two won't suddenly make her able to afford a Tesla.
If leading markets can create bubbles where carbon is accurately accounted for, the free-rider problem can be substantially alleviated and we might be able to finally make some progress on climate.
I'm less hopeful about new fuel taxes. We've seen how that's gone in France, and even Switzerland.