Re:Former Reddit Director & Harvard Fellow Charged With Hack...
by tedunangst on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @04:42PM
(#2782983)
I'm not specifically familiar with JSTOR or MIT's network, but I am familiar with other services that allow free access from anyone coming via a school's network block, and I'm also familiar with networks that will allow guest access for a short period of time so as to not inconvenience true guests.
Lots of services do this because it's far less hassle than distributing traditional credentials and typically it's less likely to be abused because unlike name/password pairs, you can't post an IP address to usenet and have somebody else use it. The abuser also has to be physically present, which makes them much easier to find.
If that's all true then the description of the events and charges seem to reflect quite a polarized view. It's somewhat understandable, though, that JSTOR would want to "throw the book at him" given his previous public comments - it seems very likely he intended to distribute the large cache of documents widely. Whether or not that's ethical, it's clearly not in the firm's best interests - I doubt a similar situation without any intent to distribute would be referred to law enforcement at all.