Re:Aaronsw indicted for hacking MIT network to download mill...
by Vivtek on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @02:52PM
(#2782464)
But: (1) JSTOR isn't a storage facility in that sense; the copyright holders do not pay JSTOR to store their items, so this is a bad analogy.
(2) If the outrage is supposed to be about bypassing security systems, why is the government hung up on the "theft" terminology? Especially when JSTOR, the party arguably injured (in some way not specified), has asked the government not to prosecute?
No, this is clearly a convenient way to get a politically inconvenient person labeled a felon.
Re:Aaronsw indicted for hacking MIT network to download mill...
by anigbrowl on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @04:29PM
(#2782930)
1. The analogy is only to point out that a 3rd party repository can be negatively affected by a break-in event if it doesn't have an ownership interest in the materials it stores.
2. The government is not hung up on the 'theft' terminology. The words 'steal' or 'stole' only appear three times in the 15 page indictment and the actual offenses he is charged with are wire fraud, computer fraud, unlawfully obtaining information from a protected computer, and recklessly damaging a protected computer.
My point is not that the government is correct or morally justified in bringing this indictment, but that getting hung up on terminology like this obscures the legally problematic issue of having (allegedly) bypassed the security systems to download material he was not supposed to have access to, regardless of who actually owns said material.