News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hyperarchy: Democracy for the Digital Era by beatpanda on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @11:50AM (#2781409)
Or we could use the freedom of information, power distribution, disintermediation and distribution efficiency made possible by the internet to obviate the need for centralized government.

I'd vastly prefer that to yet another version of allowing other people to determine my life for me.

Re:Hyperarchy: Democracy for the Digital Era by mwhite on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @11:57AM (#2781445)
It seems to me that that is exactly what this has the potential to do. It's only being framed in the language of centralized government because people might not be ready to deal with the truly revolutionary implications of such a system.
Re:Hyperarchy: Democracy for the Digital Era by beatpanda on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @12:00PM (#2781456)
Not if anyone is still bound by the decisions of the majority.
Re:Hyperarchy: Democracy for the Digital Era by mwhite on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @12:17PM (#2781556)
Just because people are bound by the decisions of the majority doesn't mean it's centralized. They may decide that the cost of sometimes having to abide by group decisions that conflict with their individual preferences is outweighed by the benefit of being part of a group with an optimal decision-making process that (presumably) provides benefits to its members that they would not get if they chose to remain unaffiliated. All the while remaining decentralized.

Reading http://nickbostrom.com/fut/singleton.html totally altered the way I look at this.

Re:Hyperarchy: Democracy for the Digital Era by slowpoke on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @01:03PM (#2781822)
>Just because people are bound by the decisions of the majority doesn't mean it's centralized.

That wasn't the point my grandparent was making. The first and foremost critical flaw of democracy is (and always will be) that the majority can dictate over the minority. That has nothing to do with centralization.

Also, it's not about "personal preferences". It's about minorities effectively being dominated by the majority, without them having any way to fight back. While there might be some basic rights to protect minorities, they are essentially always stripped of the most important and fundamental right in such a society: influence on decisions that concern themselves. That is - factually - a tyranny for everyone who is not part of the majority.