News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pandora: Giant of Internet Radio Nears Its 'Last Stand' by tptacek on Saturday August 16, 2008 @10:51PM (#278139)
I remain confused by why people believe that "the community" should be able to set price caps on artwork owned by corporations. If Warner Music wants to charge $5 a play for Mylie Cyrus, I'm certainly not going to pay it, but how is it "wrong"?

I'm surprised and happy that Pandora and Last.fm can exist at all, but I don't understand what entitles them to exist. We don't have a "right" to consume major label music.

Re:Pandora: Giant of Internet Radio Nears Its 'Last Stand' by jamesbritt on Saturday August 16, 2008 @11:23PM (#278154)
"...should be able to set price caps on artwork owned by corporations"

Because copyright protection is not a right, but a limited privilege granted by the United States Constitution and intended to "promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts", not to make a sure $ for some corporation.

Hence the idea of compulsory licensing, for example. If the cost of the license, though, is prohibitive, it has the same effect of refusing a license, which (one could argue) would interfere with the progress of science and useful arts.

Re:Pandora: Giant of Internet Radio Nears Its 'Last Stand' by tptacek on Sunday August 17, 2008 @09:27AM (#278345)
The "limit" on copyright is duration. The market owns price. You haven't answered my question.
Re:Pandora: Giant of Internet Radio Nears Its 'Last Stand' by mrkurt on Sunday August 17, 2008 @11:01AM (#278384)
That's one of the limits, yeah. You also get things like "fair use". You're correct that price is not currently a restriction in every case, but there's a good case to be made for compulsory licensing (which is partially a price limit).

Copyright law creates artificial monopolies. Market based pricing breaks down in the face of a monopoly. Given that we're dealing with state enabled monopolies, it seems reasonable that we should clamor for changes to the framework they operate under.

Re:Pandora: Giant of Internet Radio Nears Its 'Last Stand' by jamesbritt on Sunday August 17, 2008 @04:49PM (#278590)
"The "limit" on copyright is duration. The market owns price. You haven't answered my question."

Yes, I did. See the other comments on compulsory licensing as being state-sanctioned price limit, if my own answer was not clear enough.

Also, a reasonable counter-question is, what gives someone the right to prevent me from making a copy of a digital entity?

Intellectual "property" is quite different from physical goods, and the fact that the Constitution has a special clause for copyright suggests that IP was not meant to be equated with, say, land or other material things.

Perhaps copying is the real right, with government offering to restrict that right for a period of time so as to offer incentives to people to make their creations public.

Re:Pandora: Giant of Internet Radio Nears Its 'Last Stand' by mtw on Sunday August 17, 2008 @08:23AM (#278329)
Playing devil's advocate:

"... the same effect of refusing a license, which (one could argue) would interfere with the progress of science and useful arts."

So does that mean that Google or Coca-Cola should (must?) license their algorithm/recipe for the progress of science and useful arts?

Re:Pandora: Giant of Internet Radio Nears Its 'Last Stand' by rglovejoy on Sunday August 17, 2008 @08:46AM (#278335)
No, because those are not copyrights. They are trade secrets/patents, which are protected by a different set of laws.
Re:Pandora: Giant of Internet Radio Nears Its 'Last Stand' by gensym on Sunday August 17, 2008 @03:18AM (#278245)
This reminded me of an essay in last week's New Yorker about "The Permission Problem" (http://www.newyorker.com/talk/financial/2008/08/11/080811ta_...). In summary, when too many stakeholders are involved in a deal, the deal tends to fall through, because any one of the stakeholders is likely to demand nearly the entire value of the deal (since they can kill it by denying their permission).

Radio (Internet and other) doesn't exactly fit that, since you could still have a viable radio station without playing, say, any Beatles songs, but it is similar. If, in order to have an Internet radio station, you needed to negotiate with the owner of every song you wanted to play, running such a station would be prohibitively expensive. Having an organization such as SoundExchange with the authority to collect royalties for copyright holders is one solution to that problem.

That doesn't answer your question, though. One answer is that such fees are so high that they make SoundExchange useless, at least as far as Internet radio goes (as opposed to Satellite), because no one can afford it, so such fees effectively kill Internet radio. If we were talking about a free market, an appropriate response to this could be, "let them die out, and some other competitor can take their place and make a better deal with Internet radio stations". However, we're not. SoundExchange is granted monopoly power by the US Copyright Office. If, in exchange for that power, it does not grant a fair deal to Internet radio stations, then US citizens should have the ability to act through their government to change that.

Note also that individual copyright holders are granted monopolies to those works by the government. A reasonable stance, I think, is - if the government gives you a monopoly on something, you have a responsibility to charge fair prices for that thing. Prices that prevent a new industry, for which there is much demand, from growing are probably not fair.

Re:Pandora: Giant of Internet Radio Nears Its 'Last Stand' by ks on Sunday August 17, 2008 @06:56AM (#278307)
If, in order to have an Internet radio station, you needed to negotiate with the owner of every song you wanted to play, running such a station would be prohibitively expensive.

I think this can be solved using technology and micropayments. The artists could register their songs in some sort of online database, with the price they are willing to accept. This would make a free market where the artists could decide what their songs are worth.

I don't think the artists in RIAA would be the first users of this database, but independent labels might be interested. An unknown artist could set a lower price to make their music more attractive for radio stations.

Re:Pandora: Giant of Internet Radio Nears Its 'Last Stand' by aggieben on Sunday August 17, 2008 @02:29AM (#278225)
Actually, this is the solution for Pandora:

Go the route of a two-tier system, where users who listen to ad-supported music get to listen to music whose label doesn't demand more than $X, and to listen to music whose label demands too much you have to pay $Y per month, where Y must be calculated to cover the costs of the royalties. Pandora needs to realize that it's the future, and be confident about that. Relegate the music owned by extorting labels to the digital ghetto and be done with it. Eventually the great artists that are under a label will go independent, so you won't necessarily be killing off the best artists, in the long run. The important thing is that Pandora and it's investors have some balls.

This would work great for me, because the majority of the time, I don't really care all that much who I'm listening to, really; I'm after particular styles and sounds. Our current "system" of fan-dom is really just a way to keep track of what you like. If the Genome project is capable of keeping track of what I like for me,then I don't have to worry about who it is. This won't kill "fandom" either, because there will still be a handful of artists that I'll really like, and best of all, I'll discover them through the Genome's recommendations instead of ridiculous label promotions.

Re:Pandora: Giant of Internet Radio Nears Its 'Last Stand' by Prrometheus on Sunday August 17, 2008 @03:10PM (#278514)
BMI was invented to license artists to radio stations when ASCAP's fees were too high. ASCAP refused to lower their prices at first, they'd assume that nobody would want to listen to the unproven artists that BMI was signing. Fortunately for BMI and the world, people liked the upstarts just fine.

The time is ripe for another market entrant to modernize music distribution.

Re:Pandora: Giant of Internet Radio Nears Its 'Last Stand' by tptacek on Sunday August 17, 2008 @03:37PM (#278540)
This seems to me like a far better solution than attempting to legislate that businesses ignore the market. Of course, it implies that we should blame the artists, not the labels; I'm already on that page, but many aren't.

Musicians go to the major labels because the major labels own the distribution channel and the prestige that goes with it. But ten years from now, that channel is going to be meaningless. What's the business that fixes the RIAA problem?

Re:Pandora: Giant of Internet Radio Nears Its 'Last Stand' by Tichy on Sunday August 17, 2008 @05:40AM (#278284)
I wonder if it is not also the artists "fault": they chose to be represented by the music industry. Apparently alternative channels have not yet attracted sufficient talent to create a radio service based on it.
Re:Pandora: Giant of Internet Radio Nears Its 'Last Stand' by tptacek on Sunday August 17, 2008 @09:30AM (#278347)
This is basically my thought as well. Pandora is upset because without major-label artists, most of their clientele will vanish. But that's really not our problem, is it? If WMG (or their trade reps) are a bunch of bitches, Pandora should just do business with Matador.

It feels like what Pandora really wants is for their business model to be handed to them on a platter.

Re:Pandora: Giant of Internet Radio Nears Its 'Last Stand' by sabat on Sunday August 17, 2008 @10:26AM (#278368)
Besides the fact that there is no provision in the US constitution for treating ideas as property, it's wrong because webcasters are being treated wildly unfairly than other outlets. There is only one reason for this: the RIAA is afraid of them and wants to drive them out of business. That's actually illegal. And wrong.
Re:Pandora: Giant of Internet Radio Nears Its 'Last Stand' by tptacek on Sunday August 17, 2008 @03:34PM (#278539)
A WMG-owned production of Mylie Cyrus singing "7 Things" is not simply an "idea". That's a straw-man argument.
Re:Pandora: Giant of Internet Radio Nears Its 'Last Stand' by sabat on Monday August 18, 2008 @02:27PM (#279530)
Whatever you want to call it -- I use the word idea -- a song is certainly not a tangible thing. (If you can hand me a song, I'll recant. No, not that, that's sheet music, not the song itself. No, not that CD, that's a copy of the recording of the song.)

The constitution says -- I'm paraphrasing -- that 1) congress can't make laws that limit the freedom of expression (including my ability to use someone else's work to express myself), and 2) that the exception to that is for artists, who are granted a monopoly on their own work for a limited time, to encourage them to make more art.

There is NO provision for "owning" a song. And the 1st amendment trumps any law that says you can.

BTW I think you ought to look up what the straw-man argument, because I don't think it means what you think it does.