Keeping in mind that traditional radio does not pay any fees for playing music, Mike Huppe is in for a treat if Pandora is shut down. Tons of infuriated, tech savvy users will have his name and an axe to grind. I don't think SoundExchange aka the _RIAA_ (nice try Suit factory) fully understands what they're getting in to.
Also related: This is not about the artists; the majority of those fees go to the labels - not the talent. Besides what does Mike Huppe know about blood and sweat? He shuffles papers around all day.
http://pview.findlaw.com/view/1570397_1?noconfirm=1
Edit: I've been reading traditional radio still pays fees. Regardless, they are a fraction of what Pandora may have to pay.
Time Warner: 21 million USD in loss EMI: 260 million GBP loss (~ 520M USD)
There is no info on the others, but it would be hard for them to make big bucks while Warner Music Group's stock drops 74%.
This whole thing reeks because it's basically the RIAA and major labels getting into a big huff because they are losing control over the outlets that they used to control.
Presumably, terrestrial radio is not seen as a potential replacement for CDs while internet/satellite is. It's all rubbish of course.
In a way, 'stars' might be a lot worse off without piracy. Consumers might be drawn to free music given away by weird artists (Radiohead, NIN). Presumably a lot of those would be artists with 0 sales & nothing to cannibalise.
Take, software as an analogy. How many users of pirated MS Office would otherwise use Open Office? In the south, these might have become the standard if not for piracy.
I want to help find out.
Sadly that is about as much power as I seem to have without actually making an effort.
Id say it makes a lot of people angry. It's also another step in making people reconsider the concept of copyright for music.
I think someone's mentioned it here in the discussion: Copyright protection is not an inalienable right (like the right to remain silent), it's an instrument designed to have some desirable result (like tax deductions). Copyright in this case is preventing innovative products & services, and very probably harmful to the art itself. 'Small' artists & genres have the most to gain from the potential of free music.