News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple threatens UK market exit if court orders 'unaccepta... by mjburgess on Monday July 12, 2021 @07:08AM (#27809087)
The patent holder would be a company operating in the same market as apple, having a viable market for products somewhat related to the patents they hold. Eg., an electronics company.

If they can't meet that condition, sell the patent to a company who can. They'll actually innovate with it (ie., use the licence feeds to fund something useful).

Re:Apple threatens UK market exit if court orders 'unaccepta... by salawat on Monday July 12, 2021 @09:28AM (#27810020)
This means all patents will eventually flow to a single holder over time (the one most able to offer a patent buyout pipeline). This is a terrible idea without strong anti-trust and forced break-up and anti-consolidation enforcement.

I hate patent trolls too, but if your two outcomes are A) all you'll get is a bunch of umbrella companies coupling a legal firm to a modest widget mill. This is a great way to proliferate e-trash though and B ) The leviathan in town sets up a window to buy out every patent they can to save no long term litigation costs... Maybe your system is flawed to begin with.

Re:Apple threatens UK market exit if court orders 'unaccepta... by Brian_K_White on Monday July 12, 2021 @11:37AM (#27811351)
I don't see how "operating in the same field" or even "somewhat related" can be determined or valid.

Tons of technology is used in fields other than where it originated.

Probably a lawyer didn't legitimately invent an important new chemistry for a glue, but a baker could, or a landscaper, etc. And math and process/logistics can come from anyone anywhere at any time, even a lawyer.

This may be hard to define and be correct and fair about it.

Then again... in that case they'd be the originator which could be a special status vs purchased as an asset. Maybe not so hard to manage after all.

Re:Apple threatens UK market exit if court orders 'unaccepta... by MikeDelta on Monday July 12, 2021 @07:36AM (#27809239)
This is a great condition that would invalidate all patent-trolls.