News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple threatens UK market exit if court orders 'unaccepta... by tut-urut-utut on Monday July 12, 2021 @06:44AM (#27808962)
In this case, I'm glad it's actually targeting Apple. There are a bunch of small innovative companies targeted by patent trolls that don't have means of Apple to fight back and actually change the system to be more level-headed.

But I'm afraid Apple will not fight for the reform of the patent system, but will just try to protect itself. In which case I don't care about the outcome, since Apple also uses the same patent trolling tactics elsewhere to suppress its competition, e.g. litigations against Samsung in Germany, to name one such case.

Re:Apple threatens UK market exit if court orders 'unaccepta... by Tenoke on Monday July 12, 2021 @06:55AM (#27809022)
They are literally fighting it with this case, no? Exiting if they fail will also be great as it might become more clear to those who can change the system how much of a detriment it is.
Re:Apple threatens UK market exit if court orders 'unaccepta... by mjburgess on Monday July 12, 2021 @07:05AM (#27809072)
If apple's UK iPhone profits really are in the c. 50mil range, then a (5 to 10)bn fee to remain is commercially non-viable.

Note that this is about Apple's ability to sell an iPhone in the UK, and as far as I can see, it wouldnt affect whether the entire company would remain in the UK.

If I were apple, I would withdraw a product from a country which supported this kind of racketeering.

Re:Apple threatens UK market exit if court orders 'unaccepta... by inertiatic on Monday July 12, 2021 @07:21AM (#27809158)
Apple sells 7 million iPhones a year in the UK, Google tells me. Even at just 100 profit a unit, should be way more than 50 million in profit. Ignoring income from other things like accessories, the store etc.
Re:Apple threatens UK market exit if court orders 'unaccepta... by TeMPOraL on Monday July 12, 2021 @07:37AM (#27809245)
Not to mention, the complementary effects. Someone buying an iPhone today is more likely to choose an Apple device as their laptop. Someone buying an iPhone today is more likely to buy another iPhone in a few years, over an Android phone.
Re:Apple threatens UK market exit if court orders 'unaccepta... by bilbo0s on Monday July 12, 2021 @11:13AM (#27811092)
If it's only 7 million, then Apple would definitely leave.

I had no idea it was that low. I would have thought it would be from 10 to 14. To put it in perspective, Apple sells 4 times that many in China. With China and the US being their bread and butter. Also, their marketshare in China and the US has way more upside. (Room for growth.)

I can understand now. You definitely don't want to pay money to stay in a market that has less upside than your money makers. That would mean you're using money from your money makers to fund customers who are not your money makers. From a much smaller businessman's perspective, I'd file that under, "There are some customers out there that are too much trouble."

Re:Apple threatens UK market exit if court orders 'unaccepta... by Tsiklon on Monday July 12, 2021 @04:37PM (#27814788)
There are 65 Million people in the UK, China and the United States are significantly larger both in terms of population. I haven't checked the numbers, but it is not unreasonable to assume that there is a similar amount of iPhones sold per year per capita in the UK as compared to those other two markets.
Re:Apple threatens UK market exit if court orders 'unaccepta... by Mindwipe on Monday July 12, 2021 @10:07AM (#27810417)
> If I were apple, I would withdraw a product from a country which supported this kind of racketeering.

Lol. If this is "racketeering" then Apple will have to withdraw from literally every Western developed nation.

This case only didn't happen in the US because the court didn't find the patent to be valid, by a thin margin.

Re:Apple threatens UK market exit if court orders 'unaccepta... by denton-scratch on Monday July 12, 2021 @10:19AM (#27810538)
Leaving the UK market won't save them licence fees. They've already been incurred. It would be less like relatiation, more like flouncing off in a huff.
Re:Apple threatens UK market exit if court orders 'unaccepta... by lights0123 on Monday July 12, 2021 @11:50PM (#27817473)
> A court case later in July will determine whether Apple will have to make a legally binding pledge to abide by judge-set payout rates in the July 2022 trial

They haven't paid them yet. And if they leave the market, they have no reason to pay it.

Re:Apple threatens UK market exit if court orders 'unaccepta... by rchaud on Monday July 12, 2021 @12:08PM (#27811726)
Doesn't seem to be that detrimental in China. Apple always manages to work something out over there.
Re:Apple threatens UK market exit if court orders 'unaccepta... by rasz on Monday July 12, 2021 @12:58PM (#27812387)
Apple is super pro patents, they never go for patent invalidation. Case in point they got sued by S3 for S3TC, despite S3TC being stolen Apple QuickTime Road Pizza patent https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26758884, and caved in without much fight.
Re:Apple threatens UK market exit if court orders 'unaccepta... by tooltalk on Monday July 12, 2021 @04:04PM (#27814429)
Apple knows how to play the patent game and routinely petitions PTAB review to invalidate patents. I'm willing to wager that there are at least a few dozens of on-going reviews petitioned by Apple (and its proxy) at any given moment. Take for instance Apple's lawsuits with VirnetX which have been dragged out for several years appeal after appeal with multiple patent invalidations -- in one of the lawsuits, Apple ended up losing to the tune of $500+M, finally paid out in 2021. Apple is pro-patent -- and also one of the most egregious abuser -- insofaras it can game the system in their favor. Like many patent trolls, Apple also shops around for favorable legal outcome, aka, forum shopping, -- eg, Lucy Koh in Apple's backyard is one notorious example.

And who can forget Apple's patent troll operation, Rockstar consortium, that crashed and burned as it was taking off.

Re:Apple threatens UK market exit if court orders 'unaccepta... by londons_explore on Monday July 12, 2021 @07:10AM (#27809100)
> bunch of small innovative companies

The smart move for the patent troll is to target some of these smaller companies and write license agreements in the form of "I agree to pay $20 per device sold to license this patent". $20 is nothing to a company selling Ships, Oil rigs, tunnel boring machines, etc.

Then when it comes to apple, paying $20 per iphone is suddenly rather expensive, but the troll can show the court lots of licensees all agreeing to pay that rate, and it can then be established as a reasonable rate for this specific patent.