Re:Wall Street Takes Workers’ Retirement Money and Uses It A...
by peterbonney on Monday July 12, 2021 @08:32AM
(#27809574)
> But then how does the buyer make money? They buy a ton of stock of a company that still might go out of business.
But then how does the short-seller make money? They short a ton of stock of a company that still might not go out of business.
See how it works both ways?
As for everything else, I don’t know what to tell you - there is no basis in reality for your extremely narrow hypothetical construction, so there is nothing to argue with. As someone with some expertise in finance and investing I am telling you that you don’t understand what you are talking about, and I don’t mean that in an insulting way - this is complicated stuff. You can choose to ignore me as an a-hole on the internet, or you can choose to take the feedback and accept that there is more for you to learn on this subject before you offer opinions. It’s entirely your call.
A company in a precarious position has trouble finding new creditors. Not many banks will give you a loan if there is only a 50% chance you'll be able to pay it back.
> Second, believe it or not companies can go bankrupt without wiping out their stock price. Bankruptcy courts are smart enough to not give away the entire company to the debtors when they are short $1 today but will receive $2 tomorrow.
Failure to raise capital can make a company worthless when it wouldn't be otherwise. You have customers willing to buy products but no equipment to make products, so without capital the customer demand can't be turned into money. But customer demand can't be sold to a competitor in bankruptcy court.
> Second of all, and more importantly, if the stock is illiquid enough that (Downtick Rule notwithstanding) a short-seller can manipulate the price downward, that means the stock is illiquid enough to manipulate in the other direction when a buyer decides to execute the same strategy in reverse (and buyers have no stock borrow requirement and no equivalent to the Downtick Rule to worry about - you can absolutely drive up stock prices perfectly legally, provided that act isn’t part of some other illegal scheme like a pump and dump).
But then how does the buyer make money? They buy a ton of stock of a company that still might go out of business. It's less likely to go out of business that way, but you don't get to find that out for another year, and it's not so much less likely that this strategy would have the same level of profit as short selling a company that then goes to zero right away because they couldn't raise the capital immediately required to continue operations.
> Think about it this way: if short selling were the act that it is often made out to be we would see every stock driven to zero by these all-powerful short sellers.
You can't just go short Apple and expect it to drive them out of business. It only works for a company which is already at risk, to push them over the precipice.
And it's a high risk strategy. If you fail to drive them out of business you could lose a lot of money. But if you succeed, you make a lot of money at the expense of the people who lose it to you.