Re:Don’t submit to conformity
by chasil on Monday July 12, 2021 @12:13AM
(#27806981)
Let me give you a set of basic, specific operational facts that I discerned a few years ago.
NFS as a protocol engages in clear text transfers of filesystem data between the client and server.
I had some experience with stunnel, and I found a way to push NFS traffic through it, forcing either aes-gcm or (with TLS 1.3), chacha20-poly1305.
The method and complaint that I raised was heard by protocol maintainers, and resulted in a draft RFC to embed TLS at the RPC level, extending encryption to all RPC services beyond NFS.
I also later found notes of the NFSv4.2 approval suggesting that TLS should be added, but it was not. That fell to me.
"Special mention goes to Charles Fisher, author of "Encrypting NFSv4 with Stunnel TLS" . His article inspired the mechanism described in this document."
I think that it was worth the effort. It was in the back of my mind for some time, and I probably should have been more motivated to do it, for the impact it had.
NFS as a protocol engages in clear text transfers of filesystem data between the client and server.
I had some experience with stunnel, and I found a way to push NFS traffic through it, forcing either aes-gcm or (with TLS 1.3), chacha20-poly1305.
The method and complaint that I raised was heard by protocol maintainers, and resulted in a draft RFC to embed TLS at the RPC level, extending encryption to all RPC services beyond NFS.
I also later found notes of the NFSv4.2 approval suggesting that TLS should be added, but it was not. That fell to me.
I don't think that this was subjective.
If I google "onc RPC encryption," I find: https://tools.ietf.org/id/draft-ietf-nfsv4-rpc-tls-01.html
"Special mention goes to Charles Fisher, author of "Encrypting NFSv4 with Stunnel TLS" . His article inspired the mechanism described in this document."
If I google "NFS encryption," I find me: https://www.linuxjournal.com/content/encrypting-nfsv4-stunne...
I think that it was worth the effort. It was in the back of my mind for some time, and I probably should have been more motivated to do it, for the impact it had.