In the sense you seem to mean, they literally don't. Short sellers cannot drive companies to bankruptcy.
> If people want to pay a premium to not loan out their shares, let them and adjust the price accordingly.
That's an option available to you. Some brokers do let you opt in and out of lending shares. Of course, it comes with a cost.
I'm aware of this, but it's not an option for a retirement account. That's the entire point we're debating, is it not?
> Short sellers cannot drive companies to bankruptcy.
I honestly don't know how you can believe this. If they drive the price so low that the company is unable to manage its debt they are forced to declare bankruptcy, the short sellers never have to close their positions and they keep all of the profit. So not only can they do it, they have a strong financial incentive to do so.
Well, it's actually pretty easy.
1) In theory, it can't happen.
2) And in practice, it doesn't happen.
It doesn't get much more cut and dried than that!
> If they drive the price so low that the company is unable to manage its debt
....that's a bit like saying short selling costs lives, because if short sellers drive the price so low that the headquarters catches fire, people might die in the flames.
See, the problem here is that driving a share price down doesn't stop you from managing your debt. Which is a key reason why there are no documented cases of short sellers driving healthy companies into bankruptcy.
Have a good night.
(Again, I say this because there is no theoretical mechanism by which selling stock short can realistically cause bankruptcy - contrived examples to the contrary. And we know they're contrived examples because it's never actually happened.)
Your mistake is assuming predatory short sellers don't exist.
> If the short sellers are wrong, the price will not being going down long term, whether you lend shares to them or not; might as well profit from it if you can.
If people want to pay a premium to not loan out their shares, let them and adjust the price accordingly. That's how markets are supposed to work. Why do people buy Berkshire A instead of Berkshire B? I realize there is a subtle difference (apart from price), but I know people that pay the premium without knowing what it is. Shouldn't you be happy to profit from an investor's ignorance?
Make it an option and let people vote with their money. That's what markets are for.