News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Article About Startups That Wasn't Written By A Preten... by whalesalad on Saturday August 16, 2008 @05:18PM (#277967)
I have nothing whatsoever against Paul Graham, I really don't know too much about him and aren't one of the many on here who paste all of his articles onto the cube walls surrounding their toilet, and have read them dozens of times, etc.... blah blah.

However... I do think that a lot of you are shutting Ted down simply because he said shit about PG.

Ted is funny as hell, and pretty much everything he said in his "rant" is spot on.

Personal note: I submitted this at +152 points here on news.yc, let's see how far it drops! Like Google after their earnings report? We'll see :)

Re:An Article About Startups That Wasn't Written By A Preten... by tlrobinson on Saturday August 16, 2008 @05:53PM (#277996)
If by "funny as hell" you mean "good at making up phrases like 'cocksteaks'", then yes.

People like Ted Dziuba and Zed Shaw seem to have found a winning formula for getting attention on the internet: yell loudly and profanely and don't be afraid to blatantly insult people, even if it's uncalled for.

Re:An Article About Startups That Wasn't Written By A Preten... by gojomo on Saturday August 16, 2008 @07:38PM (#278061)
Shaw is a builder who also rants. Dzuiba just tears down.
Re:An Article About Startups That Wasn't Written By A Preten... by tokipin on Saturday August 16, 2008 @06:26PM (#278015)
so in other words, try to be like maddox. though maddox is a different beast, and actually has sensibility
Re:An Article About Startups That Wasn't Written By A Preten... by menloparkbum on Saturday August 16, 2008 @06:01PM (#278000)
"Cocksteak" is indeed hilarious and could have only been created by true genius. It starts out with a word that generates guffaws on its own and strengthens it with imagery of slabby meatiness. The composition of the two pierces the rational mind and draws out autonomic "laffs" from deep within the humor cavities of our reptilian brains.

I just hope his startup, a web page that lists links to other web pages, does not get in the way of his truer literary calling.

edit: </sarcasm>

Re:An Article About Startups That Wasn't Written By A Preten... by gruseom on Saturday August 16, 2008 @06:33PM (#278019)
I kind of agree. He can be a very good (though uneven) writer. You couldn't possibly take the vulgarity out of his best stuff without rendering it, uh, flaccid.

Great satirists can be witty, vulgar, and highly personal all at the same time and yet come across as hilarious rather than offensive. But you'd better be saying something good or true. If you miss the mark, you're just an asshole. The trouble with this piece is not that it's vulgar but that it's mostly unfunny and drab. And the trouble with the swipe at Paul Graham is not that it's vulgar (or even that it's personal) but that it's gratuitous.

Edit: incidentally, your last sentence strikes me as a shrewd observation.

Re:An Article About Startups That Wasn't Written By A Preten... by ojbyrne on Saturday August 16, 2008 @10:24PM (#278129)
"true genius" is a little much. Maybe appropriate for the guy who started the whole concept with "asshat."