News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Model sued for posting photo of herself on Instagram by otterley on Saturday July 10, 2021 @12:40PM (#27794628)
I don't really understand why this is a story, especially one on HN. Photographers own their photos, not their subjects. This is hardly novel.
Re:Model sued for posting photo of herself on Instagram by dynamite-ready on Saturday July 10, 2021 @12:57PM (#27794772)
Questions of jurisprudence are occasionally raised on here. The story surprised me, and in this day and age, I suspect there's a problem worth solving in this. If I stood outside you home and took pictures of you every day, should I really profit from that, without you having a say?
Re:Model sued for posting photo of herself on Instagram by ipaddr on Saturday July 10, 2021 @01:10PM (#27794868)
Should the real estate board be able to take pictures of your house to include as stock photos of the street?

Should you not be able to take a picture in public if everyone in the area hasn't signed on?

You would never be able to take a picture in a city again unless you zoom in on a leaf.

Should all security cameras point at public areas be removed?

You are in public. Outside of your home. On the sidewalk.

The other question should you be able to profit off of photos of subjects that are not you and didn't have your permission? I would say yes.. as all newspapers, mags and a lot of books would become illegal.

Would you be able to revoke your permission later?

Re:Model sued for posting photo of herself on Instagram by dynamite-ready on Saturday July 10, 2021 @02:40PM (#27795481)
Me and my wife went to the Sistine Chapel a few years back. You can't take photos in there, or in many other notable tourist attractions, without purchasing a license. Thinking about this story, does that also make sense?

I'd like to think that the model/subject should at least be able to assert their moral rights over the use of their image. Like, threaten to prohibit organisations from publishing images containing their likeness.

Wouldn't that be an adequate defence against a tort of this nature?

Re:Model sued for posting photo of herself on Instagram by otterley on Saturday July 10, 2021 @02:45PM (#27795514)
The Sistine Chapel is not a public place; they have the right to control what people do inside it (subject to the law, of course).

Also, moral rights do not include the right of a subject not to be photographed in public. Moral rights (to the extent they exist in Europe; they don't exist in the U.S.) are about rights the author of a work possesses that transcend economic rights, such as attribution and to be free of derogatory treatment.

Re:Model sued for posting photo of herself on Instagram by dynamite-ready on Saturday July 10, 2021 @04:19PM (#27796151)
In the case of a model/actor, where their image could be suggested to be a form of work, mightn't there be a conflict of interests? That photo would obviously not be as valuable, if the subject was of someone else.

As for the Sistine Chapel thing, that does make sense.

Re:Model sued for posting photo of herself on Instagram by BrandoElFollito on Saturday July 10, 2021 @03:33PM (#27795839)
I have a great photo of me and my friends in a circle taking photos of the ceiling in selfie mode waist level

For the fun of course, the quality is poor.

Re:Model sued for posting photo of herself on Instagram by bb88 on Saturday July 10, 2021 @04:20PM (#27796158)
> Should you not be able to take a picture in public if everyone in the area hasn't signed on?

For news gathering and documentary purposes, yes you can. But if you're a private art photographer, no, you should not. It's the same issue as people walking onto sets of films and then suing because the studio used their likeness without a release.

If say, I was in captured accidentally in a promotional video or in a photo in a popular instagram account, I might just sue. Particularly if the instagram account makes $50k/post.

If you're making money with my likeness, why shouldn't I get a cut of it?

Re:Model sued for posting photo of herself on Instagram by otterley on Saturday July 10, 2021 @05:34PM (#27796621)
> If say, I was in captured accidentally in a promotional video or in a photo in a popular instagram account, I might just sue.

And I’d respond with a 12(b)(6) motion for summary judgment and dismissal and demand costs. I'd also file a motion for sanctions against your attorney for filing a frivolous lawsuit.

In certain states, there are rights to publicity. But these rights limit the use of someone’s name and likeness for commercial or promotional purposes of something other than the subject him/herself. For example, if I took a photo of Dua Lipa and used it to promote my potted meat, she’d have a claim against me. But if I took a photo of her and put it in a newspaper, or put it on Instagram or in my paid magazine with the caption “hey look, it’s Dua Lipa!” — even if it were on the front cover to sell the paper itself — the elements of a rights of publicity claim would not be there; or at the very least, a First Amendment question would arise.

The fact that you might make money by selling a newspaper or access to a website that has photos of someone in it isn’t enough. As we say, that’s incidental.

Re:Model sued for posting photo of herself on Instagram by otterley on Saturday July 10, 2021 @01:07PM (#27794851)
This has been the case for as long as photography has existed. It's particularly important for a free press and a functioning democracy to be able to take photos of unwilling subjects such as government officials in public.

Besides, it's not like they're breaking into her home to get shots. Everyone has a right to privacy in their home, but not in public spaces.

Don't get me wrong; I'm not making excuses for the excesses of paparazzi, but this doesn't appear to be one of those cases -- particularly if the photographer sent a takedown demand and she didn't comply.

Finally, jurisprudence isn't at issue here. Maybe you meant legal rights?

Re:Model sued for posting photo of herself on Instagram by dynamite-ready on Saturday July 10, 2021 @02:50PM (#27795550)
I'm suggesting jurisprudence, because the law surrounding this issue doesn't seem to be in any way intuitive, and it looks like people appear to have quite different ideas about how transgressions of this nature should be addressed.

I think I'm using the word correctly.

In practice, the law is on the side of the photographer. Perhaps this is not entirely fair, and that argument seems to be a theoretical one.

Re:Model sued for posting photo of herself on Instagram by pomian on Saturday July 10, 2021 @01:46PM (#27795116)
I think it's valid. Photo was posted on an internet platform. A few people reading HN work with the internet. Who knows who becomes liable for strange legal actions like this one. It informs and then we get to discuss, about the possibilities. The article doesn't mention how she obtained a digital copy of the photo, so she could post it. That's seems to be an important point.
Re:Model sued for posting photo of herself on Instagram by verdverm on Saturday July 10, 2021 @12:52PM (#27794722)
b/c HN is post peak?