News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A small town in Sweden fights to preserve Elfdalian, a dy... by Bayart on Saturday July 10, 2021 @08:55AM (#27793049)
As someone personally close to the matter, I've come to think the action of the French school system has been overblown for ideological reasons, and that's the organic mechanics of acculturation that were very much in play in France have been completely forgotten, in particular as it pertains to urban migration, economic mobility and the growth of tertiary sector. Even if the French State did nothing, Occitan wouldn't be much better now if you look at the data from neighboring countries.

It's my personal opinion, but the reason the educational program of the French Republic was successful is because it gave an outlet to a need people had. They wanted to move up, they wanted to speak French. Don't deny them agency.

Re:A small town in Sweden fights to preserve Elfdalian, a dy... by pessimizer on Saturday July 10, 2021 @09:31AM (#27793238)
> They wanted to move up, they wanted to speak French. Don't deny them agency.

This is a manipulation. What you are saying is that in order to move up in French society, they are required to speak French, and therefore they learned French in order not to be suppressed. But you're disguising it in weird wokeness language.

You could use the same phrasing about skin-bleaching to make it sound like people who were against it were the actual oppressors, denying brown people their agency, speaking for brown people, saying that brown people are making bad decisions for themselves, and actively trying to keep brown people from enjoying the success that skin-bleaching would bring them. It's pretty reprehensible framing, but common. It's even used against brown people themselves, like in this case it's being used against Occitan speakers.

I want to note that this framing is reprehensible, regardless of the facts on the ground, or the particular subject. You could just as well be arguing for women to get breast implants, or for orthodox Jews to make themselves available on Saturdays.

Re:A small town in Sweden fights to preserve Elfdalian, a dy... by enriquto on Saturday July 10, 2021 @10:40AM (#27793626)
> They wanted to move up, they wanted to speak French.

As a native speaker of one of the languages that France is successfully removing, I find your words deeply offensive. The suppression of languages of France has not been a peaceful or voluntary process, but a very violent one. Shit; school kids were ridiculed and reprimanded by speaking other non-french languages at the recreation yards! How evil is that?

We have agency. Problem is that we are overwhelmed by a much powerful opponent that is actively trying to eliminate us. Now I'm living in Paris, and I'm sad and dismayed at the incomprehension of most native french speakers to the plight of the people of their own country.

Re:A small town in Sweden fights to preserve Elfdalian, a dy... by Bayart on Sunday July 11, 2021 @09:35AM (#27800664)
I have directly observed and interacted with quite a few people who went through that process. Those who stayed in the village, or kept a social network there despite moving to the city, more or less all speak it still despite having learned French in school and being told the patois was best forgotten. Those who despise it the most and don't speak it anymore are those who moved out, climbed the social ladder and became mid or upper class in a city. Schooling certainly favoured that outcome, but it was ultimately determined by economics. If France had followed a less radical path, Occitan, Breton and others would be declining instead of dying, but they'd still end dead soon enough.

On a side note, I find the whole victim mentality attached to that subject deplorable, in particular coming from young people who've never been through any sort of actual oppression. People have all the tools nowadays to perpetuate their language, but there's a lot more whining than actually putting the work into teaching it to their kids and actively speaking it.

Re:A small town in Sweden fights to preserve Elfdalian, a dy... by mannerheim on Sunday July 11, 2021 @01:49PM (#27803015)
If France had followed a less radical path, Occitania might be a separate nation today. There's no denying the efficacy of the French nationalist movement.
Re:A small town in Sweden fights to preserve Elfdalian, a dy... by Bayart on Monday July 12, 2021 @06:45AM (#27808968)
>Occitania might be a separate nation today

There might have been a State across the lines of Old Gascony, and one across the lines of the lands of the Counts of Barcelona and Provence. But an "Occitan nation" is pure fantasy. There's never been much of a unifying cultural force (even at the peek of the Troubadour age), even less of a political one (save for France itself). That word "occitania" wasn't even used before the 70s and it's still far from widespread use outside of Languedoc, and for some reason Italy.

People have way too many daydreams about that stuff. But having one major Gallo-Romance nation is a natural outcome, even if the way the French State was re-factored around the turn of the 19th c. looks forced.

Re:A small town in Sweden fights to preserve Elfdalian, a dy... by mannerheim on Tuesday July 13, 2021 @03:16AM (#27818338)
There had never been a Finnish state prior to the 20th century, either.
Re:A small town in Sweden fights to preserve Elfdalian, a dy... by enriquto on Sunday July 11, 2021 @02:49PM (#27803571)
The audacity of French nationalists; I love France but I really cannot stand that!

They speak of "the village", but it's in fact many major cities in the country (Marselha, Tolosa, Perpinyà, Strossburi, Brest, Naoned) that were not French-speaking less than a couple of centuries ago. For some people, anything out of Paris is a tiny country village without importance.

Re:A small town in Sweden fights to preserve Elfdalian, a dy... by Bayart on Tuesday July 13, 2021 @02:15AM (#27818076)
"Naoned", that is to say Nantes, has never been Breton speaking. Same for Rennes. They were part of the March of Brittany set up to specifically defend against the Bretons, but they successfully annexed it in the commotion left by the Norsemen. The court of Brittany became French-speaking when it moved there.

Also, nobody in Marseille writes "Marselha", If you want to do some out of place indigenous rights dog whistling, the proper orthography in Provencal is Marsiho. Normalized Occitan is of ill repute in Provence, and so is the associated Occitanism.

Re:A small town in Sweden fights to preserve Elfdalian, a dy... by enriquto on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:01PM (#27801915)
Of all places, HN was probably the last one where I would have expected to read such a disgusting defence of linguistic genocide.

I'm at a loss. Honestly cannot reply to such bullshit without strong words.

I hope some day you will understand that what you are saying is not alright, but I won't be able to help you in that. Have a good day.

Re:A small town in Sweden fights to preserve Elfdalian, a dy... by azernik on Sunday July 11, 2021 @02:32AM (#27798862)
> if you look at the data from neighboring countries.

Which neighboring countries, exactly? Minority languages in Spain were suppressed for decades under the Franco government, and intermittently under assorted Spanish monarchies and republics before that. Germany had a diglossia between Hochdeutsch and assorted local tongues, and some of those local tongues still exist because the state saw them as legitimate regional dialects of the standard language. Italy never put nearly as much of a premium on suppressing the regional languages whose literature had contributed to Standard Italian, and those dialects have survived much better than e.g. Sardinian or Franco-Provencal.

Re:A small town in Sweden fights to preserve Elfdalian, a dy... by mannerheim on Saturday July 10, 2021 @11:48AM (#27794199)
There are numerous counterexamples of minority languages that have prospered despite the presence of a majority language that granted economic opportunity. Why didn't the Finns and Estonians just abandon their languages for Russian, the Hungarians theirs for German, or the Yugoslavians Serbian? If the Occitans had had their own country, e.g., if France had been carved up like Russia or Austria-Hungary had been, I see no reason why their language wouldn't still be commonly spoken.
Re:A small town in Sweden fights to preserve Elfdalian, a dy... by blacktriangle on Saturday July 10, 2021 @09:34AM (#27793259)
"Don't deny them agency"

Dear god this is such a great statement. So many people working in international development fetishize life out in the village. Its like they want people to live in some kind of frozen time bubble as museum Fremen.