News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do patents kill innovation? The US patent office is asking by kazinator on Friday July 09, 2021 @01:50PM (#27786431)
Patents encourage innovation because without them, the moment an inventor's idea gets out, it will be copied and monetized by some corporation with the resources to bring it to market, without compensating the inventor in any way.

Now idiotically evaluated and granted patents (in particular software patents, but not necessarily just software patents) stifle innovation.

Crowd-sourcing this kind of question just seems like ploy for the USPTO to make even less of an effort.

Suppose that the answer from the crowd is "yes": patents in those areas kill innovation. What can the USPTO do with the information, other than just not hand out patents in that area? Summarily tossing a patent application takes even less effort than slightly thinking about its merit.

Re:Do patents kill innovation? The US patent office is asking by visualradio on Friday July 09, 2021 @03:45PM (#27787747)
> What can the USPTO do with the information, other than just not hand out patents in that area?

They could require the IP holder to declare the price at which they were willing to permanently release the discovery into the public domain in exchange for a one-time payment, and levy an increasing maintenance fee on a % of that price due at the end of each financial quarter.

This may eliminate unnecessary court costs and legal fees and supply chain interruptions resulting from legal disputes, while still ensuring that the original inventors are compensated and that there is an incentive for disclosure.

Suppose a defendant is notified of patent infringement and pending legal action. Instead of hiring a lawyer or halting production they could crowd-source the money to pay the inventor's fee through the patent office. The patent office then forwards the payment to the original inventor, the patent is destroyed, and there is no basis for further legal action.

Large companies may find that it is always cheaper to pay the patent office to permanently destroy each other's patents than it is to go to court, which would also level the playing field for smaller firms and startups as the discoveries would be placed in the public domain.

Re:Do patents kill innovation? The US patent office is asking by kazinator on Friday July 09, 2021 @04:17PM (#27788048)
Why not just do that for all patents from now on? It seems like a good idea.