News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You are not running out of time by reasonattlm on Monday July 18, 2011 @06:30PM (#2778619)
Beg to differ. I'd say that if you're not feeling pressed, that you have too little time left, then you don't have anywhere near an adequate view of the plausible future. A golden age lies ahead, of glittering marvels to make all that has come so far pale to insignificance. But unless we step up to the plate and master biotechnology a lot faster and better than is presently managed, all of us reading this now will miss both that future and lives of health and transcendence lasting centuries in which to enjoy it.

As I put it here:

http://hplusmagazine.com/2011/07/13/longevity-science-needs-...

"We all express the symptoms of a fatal, inherited degenerative condition called aging - or so the joke goes. It's a dark joke, but there's truth to be found in it, as is often the case in black humor. Unfortunately, all too few people think of themselves as patients suffering aging, and fewer still would call themselves patient advocates, agitating for research leading towards therapies and cures for aging. This is a sorry state of affairs: given that our time is limited and ticking away, the tasks upon the table should always include some consideration of aging. What can we do about it? How can we engineer a research community, funding and support to make real progress within our lifetimes? If you don't spend at least some of your time on this issue, then you're fiddling while Rome burns. Time is the most precious thing we have, and we live on the cusp of technologies that will allow us to gain more of it - but those advances in medicine won't happen soon enough unless we work at it."

Re:You are not running out of time by john_b on Monday July 18, 2011 @06:45PM (#2778700)
I think you missed the author's point. The article wasn't about gaining more (or infinite) time. It was about maximizing your joy in life by living in such a way that you can be proud of your accomplishments without being overwhelmed by the need to continually out-do yourself or others. How long you live is completely irrelevant to that point. And if you are not enjoying your life because you're feeling so pressed and anxious, then living forever won't change that--that's a mentality problem.

Not to mention the disappointment you might feel if you die before the onset of the much hyped biotech revolution, having placed your hopes for happiness in its arrival.

Re:You are not running out of time by Jach on Monday July 18, 2011 @07:25PM (#2778841)
While I can agree with the author's point I think it was poorly expressed (your summary is better) and the way he suggests embodying the point seems contradictory to making an effort against Death. Though I think if people did have a certain expectation to live billions of years we wouldn't have very many hurried people around, though that's just my own speculation.

> Not to mention the disappointment you might feel if you die before the onset of the much hyped biotech revolution, having placed your hopes for happiness in its arrival.

At least the disappointment would be brief since by the time you're close enough to death to feel it you won't be alive much longer. Though I would find it pitiable that a person refuses to be happy their entire life and would only be happy being essentially immortal; it seems like many 'immortalists' are actually quite content in their current lives but want that to go on as long as possible.

Re:You are not running out of time by kiba on Monday July 18, 2011 @08:28PM (#2779037)
They would also take great effort to find black swans and long shot. Living a really long life can make you ambitious.

If you're an old 75 years old, than you might be predisposed to the short term.

The young don't know they have it, and the old don't care.

If you're going to live on the average lifespan of a 100,000 thousand years and improving, than 50 years is no problem to be wasting your time on big projects.

You can wait for your space probes to report to you, make big colonization effort that span centuries, and solve scientific questions that will take decades to unravel.

Re:You are not running out of time by nitrogen on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @02:53AM (#2779854)
The unfortunate, but probably avoidable downside: the rich old people most interested in and capable of affording life extension therapy give so much inertia to the status quo that humanity's progress is thrown to a screeching halt.
Re:You are not running out of time by say_ on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @12:35AM (#2779620)
Ironically, such a world would have to be populated by people born after the epoch, not before, to fully take advantage of the conceptual freedoms it would have to offer.
Re:You are not running out of time by pjscott on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @01:26AM (#2779715)
People change. And they would have plenty of time to get used to it.
Re:You are not running out of time by tejaswiy on Monday July 18, 2011 @10:08PM (#2779293)
Wow. This reads like a Neal Stephenson novel.
Re:You are not running out of time by astrofinch on Monday July 18, 2011 @09:10PM (#2779174)
If reasonattlm is right, it may be worthwhile for me to work my tail off and sacrifice peace of mind in the short term in order to live forever in the long term. So what he says is somewhat relevant.
Re:You are not running out of time by danssig on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @09:53AM (#2780882)
You're assuming "working your tail off" has something to do with becoming rich. I've seen little evidence to that effect and a great deal that contradicts is.

No one worked harder then the miners and few died poorer.

Re:You are not running out of time by astrofinch on Wednesday July 20, 2011 @06:47PM (#2787721)
So how do you recommend becoming rich?
Re:You are not running out of time by nhangen on Monday July 18, 2011 @08:08PM (#2778978)
I don't think it's about outdoing others at all, but about outdoing your best self.
Re:You are not running out of time by philwelch on Monday July 18, 2011 @08:35PM (#2779065)
If your goal in life is to achieve a logical contradiction, you're going to die disappointed.
Re:You are not running out of time by nhangen on Monday July 18, 2011 @08:51PM (#2779114)
That's nitpicking. You get the idea.
Re:You are not running out of time by tectonic on Monday July 18, 2011 @09:49PM (#2779253)
Hey reasonattlm, I just read through your comment history and it looks like every single comment is about life extension. While I sorely hope that your optimism turns out to be warranted, I also hope that you're living and enjoying your life today, on the off-chance that it's not.
Re:You are not running out of time by dasil003 on Monday July 18, 2011 @10:19PM (#2779320)
I hope his optimism is unwarranted. While I certainly would have a hard time turning down the opportunity to live longer, I don't think greatly extending peoples lives will be good for the individuals, society or the planet. Life and death is a beautiful cycle; not something to be defeated due an overwhelming fear of death.
Re:You are not running out of time by reasonattlm on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @12:04AM (#2779567)
You'll have to explain a little harder how the great suffering currently afflicting hundreds of millions of people due to aging is both beautiful and good for them.

Or the hundred thousand people who died from aging in the past 24 hours: was it good for them as individuals? How about their families and companions?

In short, I don't think you've thought your position through particularly carefully.

Re:You are not running out of time by flipside on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @03:50AM (#2779955)
Children only come into their own after their parents have left the picture, however it is that happens.

Can you imagine being a part of the younger generation when immortality is discovered or extended longevity? Would jobs ever open up, or promotions be available? Nobody will retire at the top, so there will be extremely little turnover. How can the young hope to surpass the old if the old hold all the keys and never let go?

Sure, aging is scary, but have you really thought through all the implications of curing it? Heck, have you even thought about why it exists in the first place? There are many cancer lines that never age, so why haven't organisms evolved that never get old? If you have an answer, I'd love to hear it.

Re:You are not running out of time by reasonattlm on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @09:54AM (#2780887)
Evolutionary explanation for the origin of aging: we age because the world changes.

http://www.fightaging.org/archives/2011/03/we-age-because-th...

And the fundamental mechanisms of aging got their start in single celled life, very early on.

http://www.fightaging.org/archives/2005/02/aubrey-de-grey-5....

None of which is a good reason for suffering aging when we could do something about it: it's just the mechanistic explanation for what is.

Re:You are not running out of time by flipside on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @01:25PM (#2781974)
Interesting articles, sure, but I wish you'd addressed societal and generational impact (you can skip overpopulation concerns).

Sure, we age because the world changes, but in case you haven't noticed, the rate of change in the human world is accelerating. It strikes me as a bad idea to bet on trends that are on a collision course by their very nature. Maybe there is a way to reconcile extreme longevity with human society, but if there is, I sure haven't heard it or found it on that website.

Re:You are not running out of time by CamperBob on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @12:32AM (#2779617)
Put it this way, I'd like to see human mortality conquered, but I don't want to be alive when it happens. If you think class warfare is a problem now, wait until only the so-called "rich" get to live forever. The others will tear the world apart.
Re:You are not running out of time by pjscott on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @01:24AM (#2779711)
Why would only rich people get to live longer? Advanced technology has tended to get cheaper over time, often dramatically. I'm not saying that things wouldn't be scary and tumultuous for a while, but the alternative is to slowly sicken and decay into oblivion before you've had even a single century of life. This should not be a tough decision!
Re:You are not running out of time by bad_user on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @07:24AM (#2780373)

     Advanced technology has tended to get cheaper over 
     time, often dramatically
That's because as far as technology in the software industry goes, the bottleneck has been our own knowledge.

That's why space travel to inhabitable planets is nothing more than an utopia right now, because for achieving the speed of light we need efficient fuel that can power a space-ship for several years. As far as this problem goes, our knowledge of the universe is not the only bottleneck -- building such a ship will also be freaking expensive in terms of material resources consumed.

You really shouldn't confuse technological advancements in silicon chips manufacturing with anything else. Moore's law is severely limited to a niche ;-)

      the alternative is to slowly sicken and decay into 
      oblivion before you've had even a single century of 
      life. This should not be a tough decision!
Advocates of immortality are completely oblivious to the social challenges this will bring.

First of all -- nobody will be able to have children anymore, since that will over-populate the planet. It's already happening since humans don't have natural enemies and we live in times of peace.

Yet as a species we feel the need to have children. Personally I would give my life just so my 1 year-old boy could live a happy life. And while it saddens me that one day he too will be dead, I don't want to rob him of one of the most enjoyable and fulfilling purposes in life -- that of raising children of his own.

Of course, this is a problem of humanity in general -- we tend to be selfish mother-fuckers.

Re:You are not running out of time by nova on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @01:15PM (#2781901)
Let me humbly suggest this video: http://vimeo.com/17513355
Re:You are not running out of time by jodrellblank on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @02:17PM (#2782302)
Advocates of immortality are completely oblivious to the social challenges this will bring.

Not oblivious to them, but social challenges are so much more fixable than being dead that it should be a no-brainer.

Re:You are not running out of time by bad_user on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @04:21PM (#2782890)
Personally I think fixing death problems is only a matter of technological progress.

And in general technological problems are much easier than social ones as social problems sometimes do not admit technological fixes ;)

With the problem I outlined above, modifying humans to not feel the need for children would make us much less human than replacing our body parts with pieces made from silicon.

It is easy imagining living a 1000 happy years, but would you experience happiness at all if you were less human? And I am aware that happiness could be faked, but then what incentive would you have for living a good life and accomplishing stuff instead of living like a vegetable, as many drug addicts are doing?

And if you can't be happy, since that's the ultimate goal of everybody, than what's the point to all this?

In my humble opinion, cheating death is the easy part.

Re:You are not running out of time by jodrellblank on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @06:56PM (#2783493)
modifying humans to not feel the need for children would make us much less human than replacing our body parts with pieces made from silicon. It is easy imagining living a 1000 happy years, but would you experience happiness at all if you were less human?

When you rephrase that to: "150,000 people die every day, and you want that to continue because changing the definition of 'human' feels a bit weird" it starts to look like less of a compelling argument.

There are lots of reasons why developing life extension technologies will cause social and economic upheavals and potentially huge ripples, but fear of possible problems is not enough to make me say "well, I'm glad people died to avoid those problems".

And I am aware that happiness could be faked, but then what incentive would you have for living a good life and accomplishing stuff instead of living like a vegetable, as many drug addicts are doing?

Am I a drug addict today? Why would I be more likely to be a drug addict in 100 years?

And if you can't be happy, since that's the ultimate goal of everybody, than what's the point to all this?

Because we can (maybe) and because if we can, it's worse if we don't.

Re:You are not running out of time by bad_user on Thursday July 21, 2011 @03:29AM (#2788779)
But there are upsides to death -- yes, lots of people die everyday, but death is fair since everybody dies at some point and death also produces renewal, changing the world for the better.

And I'm not saying that we shouldn't fix it. Heck, it may even make us less selfish; we may end up for example actually caring about our planet.

But in order to do that, there are more hard problems to solve first -- tyrants will be the first to achieve longer lives, capitalism will not work anymore, we need won't be able to have children, yes we do sex for fun but we also feel the need to reproduce so doing sex will be a lot less common, we'll have to work for all of our lives as wealth will become static, there will be no more entrepreneurs, whatever brain we'll have will have limited capacity so we'll forget meaningless details like our childhood (the happiest period of life for many people).

Even seemingly simple problems are actually big -- for example, right now death is fair, but what will happen after living 1000 years with your loved one until one day when she'll get hit by a bus? Then it won't be fair anymore and you'll most likely go mad.

And the biggest problem I'm seeing -- once the genie gets out of the bottle, it stays out. People need to at least make an attempt to fix these side-effects before solving death, not after. We cannot then say -- oops, this is was a bad idea, we'll just revert.

I've had family members die. It's painful, but at least you can live with it. And if the problems that I'm thinking about won't get solved first, I'm pretty sure that fixing death is a bad idea.

Re:You are not running out of time by CamperBob on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @01:54AM (#2779756)
Yeah, it gets cheaper over time, but there will probably be at least a few years during which the technology will be more like private space travel.

Imagine if the few people who've been able to book passage to the ISS were instead the only ones who could afford immortality. Those are not going to be fun years.

Re:You are not running out of time by loire280 on Monday July 18, 2011 @11:57PM (#2779551)
Death can never be defeated - besides accidents and catastrophes, there's always entropy - but life can have some interesting twists if your life extends longer and your mind extends further.

However, I think even a few small changes to mental capacity or an extension of life expectancy beyond 2-3x will make the recipients something other than human. Our brains have many quirks that limit our ability to reason, understand, or act rationally, but those quirks are essential to our humanity and our ability to love. I think for this reason alone, few will elect to have very drastic changes made to their minds or their lives.

Re:You are not running out of time by sans-serif on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @12:05AM (#2779570)
Would you have said this back when human lifespan averaged 40? Thanks but I think I'd sign up.
Re:You are not running out of time by orangecat on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @12:35PM (#2781660)
Life and death is a beautiful cycle

Octogenarians wasting away in nursing homes unable to feed themselves or remember their children is the polar opposite of "beautiful".

Re:You are not running out of time by dasil003 on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @02:33PM (#2782383)
Forest for the trees.

Let me put it this way: Octocentarians clinging to life and hoarding resources to themselves would be a tremendously ugly thing in my eyes.

Re:You are not running out of time by orangecat on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @04:48PM (#2783006)
clinging to life

Curse those doctors and cancer researchers.

hoarding resources to themselves

The economy is not zero-sum. If we cure aging, 80 year olds will be producing goods and services of value rather than living off welfare.

Re:You are not running out of time by dasil003 on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @05:30PM (#2783174)
I was talking about 800 year olds.
Re:You are not running out of time by reasonattlm on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @12:18AM (#2779593)
Am I not living the HN dream? A challenge and a market so large as to be beyond most people's daily conception, a time in which the trillion dollar engineered longevity industries of the future are digging their first tenuous roots, and here I am doing my bit to help right at the start.
Re:You are not running out of time by uast23 on Monday July 18, 2011 @06:51PM (#2778725)
Just for your first line, feeling pressed is different from feeling depressed, and I think that the article is referring to "feeling depressed". It is more or less trying to convey the same message as yours which conveys doing something instead of sitting idle. It's just that you want to get things done in a hurry. See the analogies to believe - Gordon Gekko, Bill Gates.
Re:You are not running out of time by BrandonM on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @12:36AM (#2779625)
We already live in a golden age. Many people spend their time wishing they had lived in some romanticized past; you seem to take the opposite approach. Each new technology brings with it both novelty/convenience and a nostalgia for the past. Because of recorded music, we had a long stretch where few people knew the joy of creating and sharing music themselves.

The whole point of the article was to enjoy the journey. I hope you don't spend yours with your sights set on a distant (perhaps impossible) goal and miss out on the joys of living your life as it is today.

Re:You are not running out of time by pjscott on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @01:38AM (#2779735)
Your advice, while technically good, is a remarkable non-sequitur. We live in some pretty amazing times, and personally I have a happy life. Why would I want to become increasingly frail and infirm, and then die? It is precisely because I place such a high value on my life that I don't want to have it cut tragically short.
Re:You are not running out of time by danenania on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @01:50AM (#2779748)
Everyone and everything dies/decays/is destroyed eventually. Does it really matter if it happens after 100 years or a 1000 years or even a million? The universe will continue existing and existing and whatever time you were alive will become less than a speck of dust in relation.

¨Life is preparation for death¨ no matter how long it lasts. We are beings of transience and impermanence. If you aren´t satisfied with 80 years, you won´t be satisfied with 8000.

Re:You are not running out of time by nitrogen on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @02:58AM (#2779862)
We are beings of transience and impermanence. If you aren´t satisfied with 80 years, you won´t be satisfied with 8000.

Satisfaction and permanence are not binary attributes. One needn't find complete contentment in any arbitrary lifespan to conclude that one could be more satisfied with a long life span than a short one. Plus, the longer one lives, the more likely it is that some true form of permanent conscious existence may be discovered and/or invented.

Re:You are not running out of time by robryan on Monday July 18, 2011 @09:57PM (#2779270)
While living longer certainly benefits the individual I don't think it's a sure thing that would benefit society as a whole. Certainly it's a debate that would have to go hand in hand with any major breakthroughs in the area.
Re:You are not running out of time by yters on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @01:05AM (#2779680)
We'll never live for ever due to entropy. Obey physics, it's the law!
Re:You are not running out of time by pjscott on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @01:28AM (#2779721)
I would happily settle for a few thousand years. Even a few hundred would be a major improvement over the grim darkness of the current wither-and-die-young system.
Re:You are not running out of time by yters on Sunday July 24, 2011 @07:47PM (#2800685)
It's all a matter of what you do with the time. Back a couple hundred years ago our lifespans would be undreamed up, we're living roughly twice as long as your average medieval peasant. But it is still too short! I'm skeptical we'll ever have enough, given that we also live in the most affluent society in all of history yet we complain about not having enough.
Re:You are not running out of time by alnayyir on Monday July 18, 2011 @08:08PM (#2778979)
This is exemplary of the materialistic mindset that some people will get wrapped up in at times, missing the real point.

Disclaimers: I am an engineer, materialist, and a nihilist.