News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:F# is the best coding language today by AnimalMuppet on Friday July 09, 2021 @12:39PM (#27785572)
I don't think that's the lesson. The problem described is with maintainability. That's not political; that's technical. (It just looks political, because people say "No, you can't use that language" after they've seen the maintainability problem a few times.)
Re:F# is the best coding language today by tikhonj on Friday July 09, 2021 @01:16PM (#27786015)
I've seen this pattern before: problems encountered with a new or different technology are attributed to that technology, while comparable problems with the existing system are seen as the fault of specific teams/developers or just as the sort of natural bugs you get in software development. The same kind of problem that's seen as a clear reason to avoid the less popular tool is seen as just something to solve or workaround in the more popular case.

That's how politics generally works: there always has to be a plausible "objective" reason for something, it just doesn't have to be applied uniformly or even actually true.

Re:F# is the best coding language today by AnimalMuppet on Friday July 09, 2021 @01:29PM (#27786182)
What you say may be true in general. But we're specifically discussing being able to hire someone to take over a code base in a language, and no, the dominant languages do not have the same problem. You can find C# programmers under any rock. F# programmers? Not so much.
Re:F# is the best coding language today by peoplefromibiza on Friday July 09, 2021 @09:15PM (#27790269)
That's true, but it's not entirely true.

I've seen countless migrations to React from other equally capable frameworks because "everybody uses React" it must be the best tool!

I've seen companies picking up Python because if you wanna do ML you gotta use Python, right?

Anybody can write Python, right?

Except now you have a Python codebase written by people that pretend to know Python, while they really don't know how to write a maintainable software program in any language, it just happens that Python is the only language they "know".

And now everything sucks, but at least it's trendy, right?

Programming languages are tools, if you hire someone competent in Ocaml but force them to use Java because "it's more maintainable" you now have two problems.

IMO

Re:F# is the best coding language today by jimbokun on Friday July 09, 2021 @01:19PM (#27786046)
The maintainability problem is a political problem, because it's hard to maintain because it's hard to find developers that know the language or are willing to invest in learning it.