Re:Adaptive social networks promote the wisdom of crowds
by sysadm1n on Friday July 09, 2021 @01:36PM
(#27786258)
> These can also fail and are gameable
Gameable perhaps, but in proper meritocratic[0] systems, voting rings etc would be detected and the perpetrators hopefully banned and they would also lose the ability to participate again at a later stage, giving an incentive to play fairly next time.
Re:Adaptive social networks promote the wisdom of crowds
by forgotmypw17 on Friday July 09, 2021 @01:06PM
(#27785886)
>"Trying to get full feedback would require someone to be able to read likes of every user, not feasible."
I think that with a fully transparent system this is not only feasible, but easy.
Re:Adaptive social networks promote the wisdom of crowds
by machinehermiter on Saturday July 10, 2021 @06:47AM
(#27792510)
Thanks for this interaction. Going to think about this while I go on a walk.
These can also fail and are gameable.
The key assumptions are that people form social networks according to DeGroot process, which is not actually true. People tend to maximize objective gain not information/influence gain - usually objective is not stated and there are various ones, from knowledge, entertainment, desirability, clout/influence and power, even financial ones. Unfortunately, this does result in a divergent scenario.
As for feedback, current social networks have simplistic "like" system that only weights engagement in a hidden matter and generic desirability points with partial feedback scenario. Trying to get full feedback would require someone to be able to read likes of every user, not feasible. What could be feasible is guessing how "likeable" a post is - gaming the system.
That said, the paper is rather high quality considering its limitations. Interesting that essentially listening to a moderate number of curated but not isolated experts had best results. (Top 5 interesting enough, this being ~33% of group.)
The trick is in identifying these top performers in a real multiobjective scenario, and whether the selection strategy still works.