News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Protect student privacy: ban eproctoring by tppiotrowski on Friday July 09, 2021 @10:17AM (#27783890)
Does anyone in academia know if tests are designed on a curve? You can give a test that everyone gets 100% on (assuming they show up) and you can give a test that everyone fails. Is part of creating a test thinking about how many students in your class are capable of scoring A’s, etc or is it just a side effect
Re:Protect student privacy: ban eproctoring by mikepurvis on Friday July 09, 2021 @10:31AM (#27784034)
I had a highschool calculus teacher who was very explicit about designing their tests on an A/B/C system.

The idea was that the A section was the basic plug-n-chug versions of the problem that everyone should be able to get if you were even half paying attention in class; the B section is stuff that requires a bit more reasoning and analysis, and may have a pitfall or two, but they'll be things that were at least mentioned; and the C section is effectively extra credit— a problem where you needed to have a deeper understanding in order to figure out something novel about it, or like you needed to re-derive something from first principles in a way that was slightly different from what was shown in class, that kind of thing.

And the sections weren't equally weighted; I think it was usually like 50/30/20, or even 60/30/10.

Some people hated this, but I really liked how explicit it was. There was no mystery meat— the whole evaluation scheme was very open about its design and intent.

Re:Protect student privacy: ban eproctoring by corty on Friday July 09, 2021 @10:33AM (#27784052)
Depends on country, university and professor. In Germany, the general rule is that grading on a curve isn't allowed or at least strongly discouraged. There was a short while when such a system was acceptable, called ECTS grades (not to be confused with ECTS credits), but that was done away with in a year or so. Currently, grades are based on the lecture contents and the expectation of the lecturer for the progress a student should make. Lecturers are relatively free to do whatever they please within those bounds. If a test ends in everybody failing, tough luck, maybe next time. If that unfortunate event does repeat too often, the dean might get involved, but can't do a lot more than talk to the lecturer.
Re:Protect student privacy: ban eproctoring by allgreed on Friday July 09, 2021 @01:27PM (#27786146)
Not strictly curve grading, but when I was studying electronics one of the professors had a 9-step algorithm for processing raw scores into grades. That involved normalizing the lab scores between different reviewers (so that harshness of a particular reviewer would be compensated for). He also assigned `cos(percentage_from_other_test as radians)` instead of resits if you missed one of the tests for valid reason but had shown up on the other.

On one hand I really like the former approach and could understand the latter (organizing resits is likely a huge PITA). On the other that's the only professor I heard of that was attacked with an axe by one of his students.

Re:Protect student privacy: ban eproctoring by cutemonster on Saturday July 10, 2021 @02:37PM (#27795456)
> only professor I heard of that was attacked

How did that end, if it's not too weird to ask

> normalizing the lab scores between different reviewers

Sounds like a good idea to me :-)

Re:Protect student privacy: ban eproctoring by denimnerd42 on Friday July 09, 2021 @10:32AM (#27784045)
From my experience... it varies widely. The university will have a standard, the department will, the professor will.

I had experience taking undergraduate courses at 4 institutions in the USA and of course many departments.

I had some professors that expected the grades to fall like grade school did with 90-100 % being a high percentage. Others gave 4-6 difficult multi part problems and graded on a transparent curve. Others gave difficult problems and were not transparent about the grading scheme.

Re:Protect student privacy: ban eproctoring by nextlevelwizard on Friday July 09, 2021 @10:48AM (#27784234)
If school is using grading curves that school has already failed and there is no saving it before grading system changes.