News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by tpmx on Thursday July 08, 2021 @07:40PM (#27778925)
For nordic climates: After running the numbers I was surprised by how little benefit I'd get from geothermal drilling + heat pump for a much larger investment (like $30k including internal fitting of water-based radiators) compared to a regular outdoor air/air heat pump for $2k. Ongoing costs would be like 5-8% lower.

Modern air/air heat pumps are awesome.

Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by Retric on Thursday July 08, 2021 @07:57PM (#27779036)
Local conditions can dramatically change these numbers. In places where the ground temperature is 20C you use dramatically less energy to heat and cool with a ground source heat pump. Nordic countries have minimal need for cooling and high levels of insulation minimize the need for heating. The worst for heat pumps is simply resistance heating which isn’t that much worse than the a heat pump connected to 5C or less ground temperatures.

On top of this 30k is on the high end for ground source heat pumps.

Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by briHass on Thursday July 08, 2021 @08:49PM (#27779411)
Define 'much worse'. Even basic heat pumps in traditional air/air split systems can achieve COPs of 3-4 above freezing air temps. The modern mini splits can do that well below freezing.

Nowhere has electric so cheap that a 2x or 3x reduction in the amount of electricity used to heat wouldn't result in massive savings.

Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by Retric on Thursday July 08, 2021 @09:27PM (#27779588)
The issue with thinking in terms of normal ground temperature is two fold. First heat pumps are removing energy in the winter so the ground might normally be 4C but it drops to say 0C. Second your working fluid never reaches soil temperature, so it might end up at -4C next to the pump.

Anyway, you only receive benifits when air temperatures are below the temperature of your ground loop. If the outside temperature needs to hit -4C before that happens you’re only benefiting from a smaller percentage of the year. Further that benefit is again constrained by the delta between resistance heating and what your ground source is providing the heat pump.

Generally it takes a combination of lower cooling costs in the summer and lower warming costs in the winter to make ground source heat pumps worth it, so being limited to a few months in the winter vs a 20+k installation cost is prohibitive.

Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by tpmx on Thursday July 08, 2021 @08:23PM (#27779228)
> Nordic countries have minimal need for cooling and high levels of insulation minimize the need for heating.

I bought this lovely house built in the 1910s...

> On top of this 30k is on the high end for ground source heat pumps.

Do note that this estimate included the cost for equipping the house with water-based radioators.

Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by Retric on Thursday July 08, 2021 @08:29PM (#27779284)
Yea, the water based radiators is a different system than the common approach of having a closed ground loop connected to a heat pump. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ground_source_heat_pump
Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by aaron695 on Thursday July 08, 2021 @09:02PM (#27779483)
> On top of this 30k is on the high end for ground source heat pumps.

When I priced it, this was normal. Perhaps $20,000 would be a a good price - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMO9jvwlHFg&t=634s

Also I assume we are talking Geoexchange (For lack of a better word) not Geothermal. Temperature differentials not radioactive decay

Digging holes and installing infrastructure just costs too much money. Air heat pumps simple, things like being noisy is also getting solved which is awesome.

Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by kragen on Thursday July 08, 2021 @10:25PM (#27779920)
Your comment is entirely unrelated to the article, which is about using the very hot rock several kilometers underground to drive turbines to generate electricity.