Urs missed Cloud
He didn't merely miss it but actively rejected it. I remember pushing for Borg to be turned into a product when I was there. The stock line (which I think came from Urs) was that Google's opportunity cost from renting out its hardware was so huge that it'd never make sense to do so, because ads was a superior business model to anything else and machine demand was infinite.
This seems reasonable though. Cloud is much lower margin than ads, so what’s the proposition to move into it?
Just because I’m good at something doesn’t mean I should do it. I make a mean scrambled egg, but don’t want to go into that business.
But of course it was too late. It was essentially IE moment for Google.
If google wanted to win, I’d expect them to be more competitive.
I don’t really use GCP much but it seems like a hobby product line.
For example, they only have $4B revenue last quarter with almost $1B of losses (9% of Google’s revenue) [0], Compared to AWS’ $13.5B (12% of Amazon revenue) and Azure’s $15B (not sure what percent as this number includes lots of things that I don’t really consider cloud).
[0] https://www.parkmycloud.com/blog/aws-vs-azure-vs-google-clou...
ATM it is not wrong.
That's maybe the moment when an once visionary leader lost their grasp over the future. Instead, they start to focus on maintaining their own competitive advantage.
Exactly what innovator's dilemma prescribed...
I read somewhere it states that Urs was behind the push of google plus.
Urs missed Cloud. Half-heartedly built GAE, which is technically superior, but mediocrely implemented.
Urs decided to defund internal development, in order to boost Cloud, after realizing google was years behind. That was a laughable technical decision.
Personally, Urs shows some form of personal distaste towards a few old but still working systems, and tried to make them disappear by cutting off their resources. borgcfg was one of them. Another evidence of Urs losing touch of the technical reality. borgcfg code is right behind C++, Java, the 3rd most human written code in Google. Make it disappear by cutting off its resources is essentially making almost every engineer suffer at Google... (I am behind the effort to revitalize borgcfg, and experienced the ridiculousness behind this view).