News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The first on-orbit fuel depot has been deployed by imtringued on Thursday July 08, 2021 @04:29AM (#27769504)
Why is it convenient? Why wouldn't you just put the fuel you get from the tanker into the rocket you actually want to launch and add a another stage?

What I am getting at is that there is no difference between carrying the tank with you and sending it ahead of time and meeting up in orbit. It doesn't change the rocket equation. It just splits your rocket into two rockets.

Re:The first on-orbit fuel depot has been deployed by Cthulhu_ on Thursday July 08, 2021 @05:00AM (#27769663)
You need a bigger launch vehicle to launch everything in one go. I mean why didn't they just launch the ISS in one go? If your launch vehicle can put 1 ton into orbit, you can either have a 500kg vehicle with 500kg fuel, or you can have a 1T vehicle with an 1T fuel thing to launch separately.

In KSP you can just add more boosters and fuel to your launch vehicle, but in the real life you have to consider economics.

IIRC for a possible Mars or even moon trip, SpaceX will need to refuel in orbit as well.

Re:The first on-orbit fuel depot has been deployed by ashtonkem on Monday July 12, 2021 @09:44AM (#27810179)
KSP also allows for a lot of configurations that are mathematically solid, but impossibly expensive or complex IRL. This bends the economies of scale in ways that don’t happen with real rockets.

My favorite example is “asparagus staging”. In a normal rocket “onion staging” is where multiple liquid rockets are wrapped around a center core, and the outside rockets are drained and expended first. This allows greater thrust at takeoff, while ditching weight once you don’t need it. In KSP these outer rockets can be trivially plumbed together to share fuel, so that only 2 rockets are drained at a time. At the end the center core is left fully fueled for continued flight, since only the exterior tanks were drained.

This is mathematically correct and damn near impossible to engineer. The pumping pressures and volumes are just absurd, since every single tank would need external, severable fuel and oxidizer lines capable of feeding a single motor at 100% thrust. There’s a reason why this tends to show up in KSP and not at say, SpaceX.

Re:The first on-orbit fuel depot has been deployed by irjustin on Thursday July 08, 2021 @04:37AM (#27769549)
You're assuming the launch vehicle can carry the weight of both the tank and the payload.

Really if you want to maximize the tank size & weight you put into space, separating the two is the only way.

To steel man your point, Starship could be looked at as one giant ass tank with a small payload?

Re:The first on-orbit fuel depot has been deployed by patrickwalton on Thursday July 08, 2021 @11:17AM (#27773062)
Google "tyranny of the rocket equation"