News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by kmeisthax on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @08:59PM (#27767443)
Question: are judges expected to solve Russell's paradox?

Because a "no open source" clause presents exactly that kind of paradox. Just try and answer me this: is the ULL an Open Source license?

If the ULL is an Open Source license (perhaps because it provides all the same freedoms as one), then you can't actually use those freedoms, because of the no-open-source clause... which makes it not an Open Source license.

If the ULL is NOT an Open Source license (perhaps because of the restriction against a field of endeavor), then the no-open-source clause does not trip... which means you have all the freedoms of an Open Source license. Which makes the ULL an Open Source license.

No clue if you could use this argument in court to invalidate the no-open-source clause.

Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by bscphil on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @10:56PM (#27768042)
Ha, yes, that's what I thought initially as well. I believe the only valid possibility would be that in claiming to apply the license to the work, ST has actually failed to apply the license to the work, so all purported licenses to the work were actually invalid. Similarly if I have a license text which simply says "you may do whatever you want with the work, except that you may not receive, use, or distribute the work under the terms of this license" that's just ... a failed license.

The problem is that the ULL is actually not an open source license anyway, and this became apparent when I gave it a closer reading:

> The recipient will not take any action that jeopardizes STMicroelectronics and its licensors' proprietary rights

This appears to make political lobbying to abolish intellectual property a violation of the terms of the license, putting it in probable violation of the OSI Definition item 5: "No Discrimination Against Persons or Groups"

> This software or any part thereof, including modifications and/or derivative works of this software, must be used and execute solely and exclusively on or in combination with a microcontroller or microprocessor device manufactured by or for STMicroelectronics.

This is a clear violation of the OSI Definition item 10: "License Must Be Technology-Neutral" and item 6: "No Discrimination Against Fields of Endeavor".

So unfortunately you don't get the fun paradox like I initially thought, because the license is clearly not an open source license even without the "no open source" clause.

Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by kmeisthax on Thursday July 08, 2021 @10:14AM (#27772199)
Alright. I thought this was some weird/clever way to try and keep their software from being merged with other projects without introducing a new copyleft ala Sun/CDDL