News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by RantyDave on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @06:35PM (#27766541)
"we want to prevent counterfeiters"

Hear that? Counterfeiters. As in: criminals. Very, very not open source.

Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by danielheath on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @07:04PM (#27766772)
Counterfeiters. As in, people who harm your reputation by using your name to sell inferior goods.

They send the design files to a dropshipping company, put up an Aliexpress listing claiming the goods are endorsed by Arduino, then collect money without actually having created any value (other than to connect a factory with no quality control to a user who thought they were getting a working chip).

This is about a flood of sellers illegally using their branding - too numerous to make chasing them individually accross jurisdictions.

Saying "Design files available on request" means they want some evidence you have a use in mind that isn't "make a buck ruining everyone elses day"

Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by sokoloff on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @08:58PM (#27767435)
I’ve used somewhere between 75 and 125 “Arduinos” over the years in various projects and a device I sell in (obviously) low volume. All of the Chinese boards have worked fine for my purposes. Are they Arduinos? No. Do they work at 10-25% of the price? Yes.
Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by kube-system on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @09:07PM (#27767491)
Plenty of knock-offs are serviceable products. That doesn’t mean it’s okay to misrepresent the manufacturer of the product.
Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by AussieWog93 on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @09:45PM (#27767708)
Most don't. They'll call themselves "Wingduino" or something like that, and advertise themselves openly as "Arduino Compatible".
Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by kube-system on Thursday July 08, 2021 @12:34AM (#27768517)
Most don’t but I’ve seen some blatant offenders in my search results every time I’ve put in an order.
Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by Pick-A-Hill2019 on Thursday July 08, 2021 @12:41PM (#27774480)
I'm curious about the product you sell.

Do you make it clear to your customers that you are selling a product that uses a cheap knock-off board?

I would hope the answer to that is 'yes' so I'm curious about what their reaction/responses have been?

Do the "Arduinos" you use in your device have any markings that are different from a genuine Arduino?

Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by sokoloff on Thursday July 08, 2021 @01:54PM (#27775569)
I sell a box that performs a task. (It's a slightly specialized OBD2/CANbus scanner that uses an AVR microcontroller.) So long as the box performs the task, it could have a woodpecker typing a picture onto a stone tablet for all the users care. If it doesn't perform the task, they'd rightly complain whether it was a Genuino, a Fakeaduino, a 6502, AVR, ESP32, or Core i7.

I do not advertise the device as containing any specific board and the vendor I buy from does not use the Arduino mark either. https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32799911396.html?spm=a2g0s.9...

Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by ineedasername on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @09:30PM (#27767627)
Apart from the problem of claiming Arduino endorsement, they do add value:

they "make a buck" by organizing the production & sales of a product at a more competitive price. It puts an educational board in the hands of people that might not otherwise afford it: On small school budgets a STEM program might not be able to afford $20 for 500 students each year, while $5 is easier to manage. Or it might mean the program can afford both a cheap Arduino clone and cheap Pi Zeros to learn development at multiple levels and different languages.

Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by kube-system on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @09:00PM (#27767453)
It is absolutely possible to counterfeit open sourced designs. Copyrights and trademarks are entirely different types of IP.
Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by goodpoint on Thursday July 08, 2021 @09:09AM (#27771452)
Copyrights and trademarks are entirely different types of IP.

...therefore it's possible to infringe THE TRADEMARK with a counterfeit product.

There is no such thing as counterfeiting the open source design.

EDIT: I'll add examples, it might help with the downvotes I'm getting:

- an OEM can make exact copies of a truly OH board but sell it under a different name and brand. Trademark is safe and Open Source is working as intended.

- another OEM can make its own Arduino clone with a different PCB layout and slap the Arduino logo and name on it. Trademark is breached and openness is lost and this is already happening.