News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Defeating Cookie Banners by TeMPOraL on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @05:08AM (#27758997)
Nice, I like it!

Of course, you won't be able to get away with just a simple checkbox there - to give informed consent, I need to be able to review what data is being sent, to whom, and for what purpose. Some kind of popup or summary page will still be needed. However, this has a much different feel to it - as a user, I'd feel respected by you, and I might actually be inclined to opt-in as a favor to you.

RE details screen: given the data is already collected, a smart enough screen could let the user inspect actual data, not just promises. That's probably too much work and isn't going to happen unless someone like you implements this as plug-and-play components, but I imagine a details screen giving me summary like:

  - Google Analytics
    - Your mouse movements (24213 data points)
    - Which links you clicked, and when
      - 12 internal
      - 2 leading to external sites
  - EvilNoGoodCorp Ltd
    - Input events in text boxes (234 characters)
      [click here] to show recording
In a hypothetical, perfect world, most users wouldn't even look at any of this. But some might skim it, expand it here end there, and the few privacy-conscious users would read through them, ready to raise alarm if something is off. This would be a very meaningful step for the industry to regain trust of the users, making people more comfortable with some level of telemetry.

As I see it, there is a place for analytics on websites and in software, but it has to be respectful, opt-in, in a culture of mutual help. A nice company asks me to do them a favor and let them watch me as I use their services? Sure, why not. If it helps them make the service better, or stay afloat for longer, I might benefit too. That's a polar opposite of the current culture, where companies feel entitled to as much data as they can possibly get.

On the technical side, I appreciate the detailed writeup. I didn't know you could inject CSP entries at runtime! And then:

> We detect JavaScript network API events by patching and overriding all of the global interfaces used to create network requests, such as XMLHttpRequest(), fetch(), and navigator.sendBeacon().

Holy shit you can do that?! That's impressive, in a positive way, both in terms of the browsers allowing this, and you finding a good use for it.

There are no comments on this comment yet.