News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Roll your own minilanguages with mini-interpreters (1989) by pjc50 on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @02:42AM (#27758097)
At this point rather a lot more weight is being put on the DSL than a mere minilanguage, so I'd embed a language interpreter for something existing. I've used Tcl for this in the past.

But when you say "users", that indicates a different use case anyway. The minilanguage is basically source compression or code generation, it's for the developers.

> your users are asking you to change the syntax und use lisp-like evaluation/expressions

Nobody ever wants that except Lisp users, and if you're surrounded by angry lisp users you should just give them what they want and embed a lisp. Or even just write one, Scheme is small enough.

But as far as I can tell, "free monads" are a lot of machinery to re-implement imperative stateful programming when you could have just used a language that wasn't Haskell in the first place.

Re:Roll your own minilanguages with mini-interpreters (1989) by valenterry on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @03:05AM (#27758232)
> At this point rather a lot more weight is being put on the DSL than a mere minilanguage, so I'd embed a language interpreter for something existing.

Sure, but then why not just use the (host) programming language directly?

> But when you say "users", that indicates a different use case anyway. The minilanguage is basically source compression or code generation, it's for the developers.

I meant developers as well - they are still users of your language no? :)

> Nobody ever wants that except Lisp users

If you are just going to disregard all use-cases and examples I give, then of course in the end we will end up with a solution-space where all my arguments don't apply. You said you can't imagine such a situation, I gave you an example. I can't really do more than that.

> But as far as I can tell, "free monads" are a lot of machinery to re-implement imperative stateful programming

Not at all. And free monads are completely orthogonal to Haskell and very useful in non-pure-functional programming languages as well. I think this conversation is not very fruitful without a basic understanding of what they are.