Basically, anything but enabling treacherous design.
This new consent manager makes it easier for site owners to offer incentives to consent (e.g. share your user journey for 5% off at checkout).
Note: 'Selling your privacy' (and likely incentivizing consent) may not be legal under some regimes, so nuance should be applied to any novel implementations using our consent manager. We have a privacy legal regime detection API which helps enable varying UI & behavior based on user-applicable legal regimes.
(Please don't say IP geolocation.)
This method even supports the nuance of detecting a EU-likely user vacationing in California, affording them both CPRA and GDPR protections. You can try out this API by typing `await airgap.getRegimes()` in your browser console on this blog post.
This method won't scale forever as more states and countries enact new privacy laws so we do plan on eventually falling back to IP geolocation as well.
await airgap.getRegimes()
to unwrap the promise and display the regime set directly in the output :).Also, I can confirm it correctly identifies the regime applicable to me (GDPR).
EDIT: I played a bit more with your blog post, after disabling my Adblock and tracking protection features in Firefox. It seems you're dogfooding your system here and now; I don't see any analytics calls happening beyond the scripts being loaded, and I also see a bunch of requests being trapped by airgap (I found it by doing airgap.export("foo") in the console). Nice work!
(So, what kind of analytics are you getting from this blogpost without asking? ;))
Or maybe asked differently: Is people giving actual informed consent to tracking actually a thing? I mean for most people I know, the reaction to such banners is one of:
I can't remember anyone who ever really wanted to agree to such stuff. Of course I haven't done any reliable research on this and it might just be my sampling bias, but I would expect any system which really gives people a choice to get very little positive responses. (On the other hand people are also trained to accept things like ToS without thinking at the end of the user journey, so maybe it works out fine...)Don't get me wrong, I really like the idea and hope that it will be successful. I just don't see users agreeing to this.